Grades / Best QBs
Quarterbacks · best value for the slot

Best NFL draft picks: quarterbacks

The quarterbacks who did the most with their draft slot. Every 2000–2025 first-three-round pick is scored against what its slot usually produces, and Aaron Rodgers (QB, Packers, 24th overall in 2005) leads at 534% of slot value. Counting every round, the top pick is Tom Brady (QB, Patriots, 199th overall in 2000), at 2,759%. Set your own bust line and rounds below and the list re-ranks.

Year
Player
Pick
Value vs slot
Career
Grade
2005
Aaron Rodgers
Packers · California · QB
Rd 1pick #24
534% HIT
10 Pro Bowls · 4 All-Pro · 16 yrs starting
462 pts vs 86 expected
A
2001
Drew Brees
Chargers · Purdue · QB
Rd 2pick #32
480% HIT
13 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 19 yrs starting
406 pts vs 85 expected
A
2012
Russell Wilson
Seahawks · Wisconsin · QB
Rd 3pick #75
470% HIT
10 Pro Bowls · 12 yrs starting
231 pts vs 49 expected
A
2004
Ben Roethlisberger
Steelers · Miami (OH) · QB
Rd 1pick #11
233% HIT
6 Pro Bowls · 17 yrs starting
268 pts vs 115 expected
A
2009
Matthew Stafford
Lions · Georgia · QB
Rd 1pick #1
205% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 16 yrs starting
288 pts vs 141 expected
A
2008
Matt Ryan
Falcons · Boston Col. · QB
Rd 1pick #3
214% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 15 yrs starting
275 pts vs 128 expected
A
2004
Philip Rivers
Giants · North Carolina St. · QB
Rd 1pick #4
212% HIT
8 Pro Bowls · 15 yrs starting
272 pts vs 128 expected
A
2018
Lamar Jackson
Ravens · Louisville · QB
Rd 1pick #32
267% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 7 yrs starting
226 pts vs 85 expected
A
2017
Patrick Mahomes
Chiefs · Texas Tech · QB
Rd 1pick #10
217% HIT
6 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 8 yrs starting
251 pts vs 116 expected
A
2014
Derek Carr
Raiders · Fresno St. · QB
Rd 2pick #36
224% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 11 yrs starting
182 pts vs 81 expected
A
2011
Andy Dalton
Bengals · TCU · QB
Rd 2pick #35
206% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 11 yrs starting
173 pts vs 84 expected
A
2004
Eli Manning
Chargers · Mississippi · QB
Rd 1pick #1
159% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 14 yrs starting
223 pts vs 141 expected
B
2008
Joe Flacco
Ravens · Delaware · QB
Rd 1pick #18
185% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 12 yrs starting
179 pts vs 97 expected
B
2004
Matt Schaub
Falcons · Virginia · QB
Rd 3pick #90
286% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 7 yrs starting
121 pts vs 42 expected
A
2018
Josh Allen
Bills · Wyoming · QB
Rd 1pick #7
160% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 8 yrs starting
192 pts vs 120 expected
B
2005
Alex Smith
49ers · Utah · QB
Rd 1pick #1
143% FAIR
3 Pro Bowls · 14 yrs starting
202 pts vs 141 expected
B
2003
Carson Palmer
Bengals · USC · QB
Rd 1pick #1
139% FAIR
3 Pro Bowls · 12 yrs starting
196 pts vs 141 expected
B
2011
Cam Newton
Panthers · Auburn · QB
Rd 1pick #1
133% FAIR
3 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 9 yrs starting
187 pts vs 141 expected
B
2020
Jalen Hurts
Eagles · Oklahoma · QB
Rd 2pick #53
164% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 5 yrs starting
99 pts vs 60 expected
B
2013
Geno Smith
Jets · West Virginia · QB
Rd 2pick #39
149% FAIR
2 Pro Bowls · 6 yrs starting
107 pts vs 72 expected
B
2002
Josh McCown
Cardinals · Sam Houston St. · QB
Rd 3pick #81
172% HIT
5 yrs starting
76 pts vs 44 expected
B
2006
Jay Cutler
Broncos · Vanderbilt · QB
Rd 1pick #11
125% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 10 yrs starting
144 pts vs 115 expected
B
2012
Ryan Tannehill
Dolphins · Texas A&M · QB
Rd 1pick #8
123% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 10 yrs starting
145 pts vs 118 expected
C
2016
Jacoby Brissett
Patriots · North Carolina St. · QB
Rd 3pick #91
159% HIT
4 yrs starting
67 pts vs 42 expected
B
2016
Jared Goff
Rams · California · QB
Rd 1pick #1
118% FAIR
5 Pro Bowls · 9 yrs starting
165 pts vs 141 expected
C
2012
Nick Foles
Eagles · Arizona · QB
Rd 3pick #88
126% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 3 yrs starting
54 pts vs 43 expected
B
2001
Michael Vick
Falcons · Virginia Tech · QB
Rd 1pick #1
101% FAIR
4 Pro Bowls · 7 yrs starting
142 pts vs 141 expected
C
2010
Colt McCoy
Browns · Texas · QB
Rd 3pick #85
80% FAIR
2 yrs starting
34 pts vs 43 expected
C
2014
Jimmy Garoppolo
Patriots · Eastern Illinois · QB
Rd 2pick #62
85% FAIR
3 yrs starting
51 pts vs 60 expected
C
2020
Justin Herbert
Chargers · Oregon · QB
Rd 1pick #6
93% FAIR
2 Pro Bowls · 6 yrs starting
115 pts vs 124 expected
C
2008
Chad Henne
Dolphins · Michigan · QB
Rd 2pick #57
83% FAIR
3 yrs starting
50 pts vs 60 expected
C
2007
Trent Edwards
Bills · Stanford · QB
Rd 3pick #92
70% FAIR
2 yrs starting
30 pts vs 42 expected
C
2005
Jason Campbell
Commanders · Auburn · QB
Rd 1pick #25
84% FAIR
5 yrs starting
73 pts vs 86 expected
C
2014
Teddy Bridgewater
Vikings · Louisville · QB
Rd 1pick #32
79% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 4 yrs starting
67 pts vs 85 expected
C
2000
Chad Pennington
Jets · Marshall · QB
Rd 1pick #18
81% FAIR
5 yrs starting
78 pts vs 97 expected
C
2018
Baker Mayfield
Browns · Oklahoma · QB
Rd 1pick #1
85% FAIR
2 Pro Bowls · 7 yrs starting
120 pts vs 141 expected
C
2021
Davis Mills
Texans · Stanford · QB
Rd 3pick #67
59% FAIR
2 yrs starting
31 pts vs 53 expected
C
2018
Sam Darnold
Jets · USC · QB
Rd 1pick #3
82% FAIR
2 Pro Bowls · 6 yrs starting
105 pts vs 128 expected
C
2011
Colin Kaepernick
49ers · Nevada · QB
Rd 2pick #36
70% FAIR
4 yrs starting
57 pts vs 81 expected
C
2006
Tarvaris Jackson
Vikings · Alabama St. · QB
Rd 2pick #64
59% FAIR
2 yrs starting
35 pts vs 59 expected
C
2003
Chris Simms
Buccaneers · Texas · QB
Rd 3pick #97
39% BUST
1 yr starting
16 pts vs 41 expected
D
2006
Kellen Clemens
Jets · Oregon · QB
Rd 2pick #49
57% FAIR
2 yrs starting
36 pts vs 64 expected
C
2016
Cody Kessler
Browns · USC · QB
Rd 3pick #93
34% BUST
1 yr starting
14 pts vs 42 expected
D
2017
C.J. Beathard
49ers · Iowa · QB
Rd 3pick #104
22% BUST
32 games played
8 pts vs 37 expected
D
2018
Mason Rudolph
Steelers · Oklahoma St. · QB
Rd 3pick #76
40% BUST
1 yr starting
19 pts vs 48 expected
D
2001
Quincy Carter
Cowboys · Georgia · QB
Rd 2pick #53
49% FAIR
2 yrs starting
30 pts vs 60 expected
C
2013
Mike Glennon
Buccaneers · North Carolina St. · QB
Rd 3pick #73
39% BUST
1 yr starting
20 pts vs 51 expected
D
2020
Tua Tagovailoa
Dolphins · Alabama · QB
Rd 1pick #5
73% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 6 yrs starting
92 pts vs 126 expected
C
2017
Deshaun Watson
Texans · Clemson · QB
Rd 1pick #12
68% FAIR
3 Pro Bowls · 4 yrs starting
78 pts vs 115 expected
C
2006
Charlie Whitehurst
Chargers · Clemson · QB
Rd 3pick #81
14% BUST
25 games played
6 pts vs 44 expected
F
Showing 50 of 116

Best NFL draft picks: quarterbacks, ranked

Quarterbacks are the picks graded here. Each is compared with what the same draft slot usually produces: a pick that returns 40% or less of that counts as a bust at the default line, and 150% or more counts as a hit. Players drafted since 2022 are left off the ranking, because a young career has not had time to prove or disprove the pick.

Quarterbacks against the rest of the draft

Of 136 quarterbacks drafted in rounds 1–3 from 2000 to 2025, 13% were hits and 43% were busts at the 40% line, against 19% and 30% for all positions. Quarterbacks bust more often than the league as a whole.

RoundPicksHit rateBust rateValue vs slot
Round 17713%29%82%
Round 22516%48%86%
Round 33412%74%56%

Looking at the other side? See the qb busts. Each player links to a page with the full pick-by-pick grade, and team grades and GM grades roll these picks up.

Want the on-field numbers? See NFL stat leaders and records for quarterbacks on StatsLedger →

More NFL draft lists

Best picks by position

Biggest busts by position

Every list re-grades at the bust line you set. Back to the homepage, or see every draft class and how the grades work.