Grades / Defensive back busts
Defensive backs · worst value for the slot

Biggest NFL draft busts: defensive backs

The defensive backs who fell furthest short of their draft slot. Every 2000–2025 first-three-round pick is scored against what its slot usually produces, and Justin Gilbert (DB, Browns, 8th overall in 2014) is the biggest miss at 7% of slot value. At the default 40% bust line, 29% of defensive backs count as busts. Move the line below and the list re-ranks.

Year
Player
Pick
Value vs slot
Career
Grade
2014
Justin Gilbert
Browns · Oklahoma St. · DB
Rd 1pick #8
7% BUST
35 games played
9 pts vs 118 expected
F
2013
Dee Milliner
Jets · Alabama · DB
Rd 1pick #9
13% BUST
1 yr starting
15 pts vs 116 expected
F
2020
Jeff Okudah
Lions · Ohio St. · CB
Rd 1pick #3
25% BUST
2 yrs starting
33 pts vs 128 expected
D
2020
Damon Arnette
Raiders · Ohio St. · CB
Rd 1pick #19
4% BUST
15 games played
4 pts vs 96 expected
F
2006
Tye Hill
Rams · Clemson · DB
Rd 1pick #15
10% BUST
40 games played
10 pts vs 100 expected
F
2011
Ras-I Dowling
Patriots · Virginia · DB
Rd 2pick #33
4% BUST
12 games played
3 pts vs 85 expected
F
2020
C.J. Henderson
Jaguars · Florida · CB
Rd 1pick #9
30% BUST
2 yrs starting
35 pts vs 116 expected
D
2015
Kevin Johnson
Texans · Wake Forest · CB
Rd 1pick #16
17% BUST
64 games played
16 pts vs 97 expected
F
2021
Caleb Farley
Titans · Virginia Tech · DB
Rd 1pick #22
6% BUST
21 games played
5 pts vs 82 expected
F
2003
Andre Woolfolk
Titans · Oklahoma · DB
Rd 1pick #28
11% BUST
39 games played
10 pts vs 86 expected
F
2001
Willie Middlebrooks
Broncos · Minnesota · DB
Rd 1pick #24
16% BUST
56 games played
14 pts vs 86 expected
F
2013
D.J. Hayden
Raiders · Houston · DB
Rd 1pick #12
37% BUST
2 yrs starting
43 pts vs 115 expected
D
2006
Jimmy Williams
Falcons · Virginia Tech · DB
Rd 2pick #37
9% BUST
27 games played
7 pts vs 79 expected
F
2020
Jeff Gladney
Vikings · TCU · CB
Rd 1pick #31
17% BUST
1 yr starting
14 pts vs 85 expected
F
2000
Rashard Anderson
Panthers · Jackson St. · DB
Rd 1pick #23
19% BUST
1 yr starting
17 pts vs 86 expected
F
2017
Gareon Conley
Raiders · Ohio St. · CB
Rd 1pick #24
21% BUST
1 yr starting
18 pts vs 86 expected
D
2019
Deandre Baker
Giants · Georgia · CB
Rd 1pick #30
19% BUST
1 yr starting
17 pts vs 85 expected
F
2002
Mike Rumph
49ers · Miami (FL) · DB
Rd 1pick #27
24% BUST
1 yr starting
21 pts vs 86 expected
D
2015
Trae Waynes
Vikings · Michigan St. · CB
Rd 1pick #11
43% FAIR
3 yrs starting
50 pts vs 115 expected
C
2014
Darqueze Dennard
Bengals · Michigan St. · DB
Rd 1pick #24
25% BUST
87 games played
22 pts vs 86 expected
D
2004
Ricardo Colclough
Steelers · Tusculum · DB
Rd 2pick #38
14% BUST
43 games played
11 pts vs 75 expected
F
2006
Jason Allen
Dolphins · Tennessee · DB
Rd 1pick #16
36% BUST
1 yr starting
35 pts vs 97 expected
D
2015
Jalen Collins
Falcons · LSU · CB
Rd 2pick #42
9% BUST
24 games played
6 pts vs 67 expected
F
2004
Sean Taylor
Commanders · Miami (FL) · DB
Rd 1pick #5
52% FAIR
2 Pro Bowls · 4 yrs starting
66 pts vs 126 expected
C
2001
Jamar Fletcher
Dolphins · Wisconsin · DB
Rd 1pick #26
30% BUST
105 games played
26 pts vs 86 expected
D
2015
Senquez Golson
Steelers · Mississippi · CB
Rd 2pick #56
0% BUST
Did not play
0 pts vs 60 expected
F
2019
Marquise Blair
Seahawks · Utah · S
Rd 2pick #47
10% BUST
26 games played
7 pts vs 66 expected
F
2000
Dwayne Goodrich
Cowboys · Tennessee · DB
Rd 2pick #49
6% BUST
16 games played
4 pts vs 64 expected
F
2017
Quincy Wilson
Colts · Florida · CB
Rd 2pick #46
12% BUST
33 games played
8 pts vs 67 expected
F
2014
Stanley Jean-Baptiste
Saints · Nebraska · DB
Rd 2pick #58
2% BUST
5 games played
1 pts vs 60 expected
F
2017
Obi Melifonwu
Raiders · Connecticut · S
Rd 2pick #56
3% BUST
7 games played
2 pts vs 60 expected
F
2016
Vernon Hargreaves III
Buccaneers · Florida · CB
Rd 1pick #11
50% FAIR
4 yrs starting
57 pts vs 115 expected
C
2009
Alphonso Smith
Broncos · Wake Forest · DB
Rd 2pick #37
26% BUST
1 yr starting
21 pts vs 79 expected
D
2015
D'Joun Smith
Colts · Florida Atlantic · CB
Rd 3pick #65
2% BUST
5 games played
1 pts vs 59 expected
F
2020
Noah Igbinoghene
Dolphins · Auburn · CB
Rd 1pick #30
33% BUST
1 yr starting
28 pts vs 85 expected
D
2008
Terrence Wheatley
Patriots · Colorado · DB
Rd 2pick #62
5% BUST
12 games played
3 pts vs 60 expected
F
2019
Joejuan Williams
Patriots · Vanderbilt · CB
Rd 2pick #45
16% BUST
42 games played
11 pts vs 67 expected
F
2009
Darcel McBath
Broncos · Texas Tech · DB
Rd 2pick #48
14% BUST
37 games played
9 pts vs 65 expected
F
2000
Lloyd Harrison
Commanders · North Carolina St. · DB
Rd 3pick #64
7% BUST
16 games played
4 pts vs 59 expected
F
2018
Josh Jackson
Packers · Iowa · CB
Rd 2pick #45
18% BUST
49 games played
12 pts vs 67 expected
F
2014
Calvin Pryor
Jets · Louisville · DB
Rd 1pick #18
43% FAIR
3 yrs starting
42 pts vs 97 expected
C
2010
Chris Cook
Vikings · Virginia · DB
Rd 2pick #34
36% BUST
2 yrs starting
30 pts vs 85 expected
D
2013
Matt Elam
Ravens · Florida · DB
Rd 1pick #32
36% BUST
2 yrs starting
30 pts vs 85 expected
D
2016
Artie Burns
Steelers · Miami (FL) · CB
Rd 1pick #25
38% BUST
1 yr starting
33 pts vs 86 expected
D
2021
Kelvin Joseph
Cowboys · Kentucky · DB
Rd 2pick #44
13% BUST
33 games played
8 pts vs 62 expected
F
2018
Duke Dawson
Patriots · Florida · CB
Rd 2pick #56
11% BUST
26 games played
7 pts vs 60 expected
F
2012
Morris Claiborne
Cowboys · LSU · DB
Rd 1pick #6
57% FAIR
5 yrs starting
71 pts vs 124 expected
C
2019
Johnathan Abram
Raiders · Mississippi St. · S
Rd 1pick #27
39% BUST
2 yrs starting
34 pts vs 86 expected
D
2000
Jacoby Shepherd
Rams · Oklahoma St. · DB
Rd 2pick #62
13% BUST
30 games played
8 pts vs 60 expected
F
2021
Jaycee Horn
Panthers · South Carolina · DB
Rd 1pick #8
52% FAIR
2 Pro Bowls · 3 yrs starting
56 pts vs 108 expected
C
Showing 50 of 443

Biggest NFL draft busts: defensive backs, ranked

Defensive backs are the picks graded here. Each is compared with what the same draft slot usually produces: a pick that returns 40% or less of that counts as a bust at the default line, and 150% or more counts as a hit. Players drafted since 2022 are left off the ranking, because a young career has not had time to prove or disprove the pick.

Defensive backs against the rest of the draft

Of 521 defensive backs drafted in rounds 1–3 from 2000 to 2025, 17% were hits and 29% were busts at the 40% line, against 19% and 30% for all positions. Defensive backs bust less often than the league as a whole.

RoundPicksHit rateBust rateValue vs slot
Round 114114%21%95%
Round 219018%23%95%
Round 319017%41%82%

Which teams draft defensive backs best

With at least eight defensive backs picks, the Cardinals (142% of slot value, 17 picks), Bears (129% of slot value, 13 picks) and Ravens (124% of slot value, 13 picks) have gotten the most from the position. The Raiders (64%, 20 picks), Vikings (66%, 19 picks) and Colts (70%, 22 picks) have gotten the least.

Looking at the other side? See the best defensive backs. Each player links to a page with the full pick-by-pick grade, and team grades and GM grades roll these picks up.

More NFL draft lists

Best picks by position

Biggest busts by position

Every list re-grades at the bust line you set. Back to the homepage, or see every draft class and how the grades work.