Grades / Best defensive linemen
Defensive line · best value for the slot

Best NFL draft picks: defensive line

The defensive line who did the most with their draft slot. Every 2000–2025 first-three-round pick is scored against what its slot usually produces, and Calais Campbell (DE, Cardinals, 50th overall in 2008) leads at 465% of slot value. Counting every round, the top pick is Jared Allen (DE, Chiefs, 126th overall in 2004), at 859%. Set your own bust line and rounds below and the list re-ranks.

Year
Player
Pick
Value vs slot
Career
Grade
2008
Calais Campbell
Cardinals · Miami (FL) · DE
Rd 2pick #50
465% HIT
6 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 17 yrs starting
289 pts vs 62 expected
A
2002
Julius Peppers
Panthers · North Carolina · DE
Rd 1pick #2
254% HIT
9 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 16 yrs starting
347 pts vs 136 expected
A
2011
Cameron Heyward
Steelers · Ohio St. · DE
Rd 1pick #31
330% HIT
7 Pro Bowls · 4 All-Pro · 13 yrs starting
279 pts vs 85 expected
A
2011
Cameron Jordan
Saints · California · DE
Rd 1pick #24
315% HIT
8 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 15 yrs starting
272 pts vs 86 expected
A
2014
Aaron Donald
Rams · Pittsburgh · DT
Rd 1pick #13
263% HIT
10 Pro Bowls · 8 All-Pro · 10 yrs starting
296 pts vs 112 expected
A
2002
Dwight Freeney
Colts · Syracuse · DE
Rd 1pick #11
236% HIT
7 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
273 pts vs 115 expected
A
2003
Kevin Williams
Vikings · Oklahoma St. · DT
Rd 1pick #9
230% HIT
6 Pro Bowls · 5 All-Pro · 12 yrs starting
267 pts vs 116 expected
A
2016
Chris Jones
Chiefs · Mississippi St. · DT
Rd 2pick #37
278% HIT
7 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 10 yrs starting
218 pts vs 79 expected
A
2001
Richard Seymour
Patriots · Georgia · DE
Rd 1pick #6
209% HIT
7 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
259 pts vs 124 expected
A
2007
Brandon Mebane
Seahawks · California · DT
Rd 3pick #85
412% HIT
13 yrs starting
176 pts vs 43 expected
A
2011
J.J. Watt
Texans · Wisconsin · DE
Rd 1pick #11
203% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 5 All-Pro · 10 yrs starting
234 pts vs 115 expected
A
2001
Justin Smith
Bengals · Missouri · DE
Rd 1pick #4
185% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 14 yrs starting
237 pts vs 128 expected
B
2011
Jurrell Casey
Titans · USC · DT
Rd 3pick #77
333% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 9 yrs starting
156 pts vs 47 expected
A
2004
Vince Wilfork
Patriots · Miami (FL) · NT
Rd 1pick #21
214% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
199 pts vs 93 expected
A
2010
Linval Joseph
Giants · East Carolina · DT
Rd 2pick #46
257% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 11 yrs starting
173 pts vs 67 expected
A
2006
Haloti Ngata
Ravens · Oregon · DT
Rd 1pick #12
190% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 12 yrs starting
219 pts vs 115 expected
B
2000
John Abraham
Jets · South Carolina · DE
Rd 1pick #13
189% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
212 pts vs 112 expected
B
2012
Fletcher Cox
Eagles · Mississippi St. · DT
Rd 1pick #12
186% HIT
6 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 12 yrs starting
215 pts vs 115 expected
B
2010
Ndamukong Suh
Lions · Nebraska · DT
Rd 1pick #2
173% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 12 yrs starting
236 pts vs 136 expected
B
2004
Darnell Dockett
Cardinals · Florida St. · DT
Rd 3pick #64
266% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 10 yrs starting
158 pts vs 59 expected
A
2015
Danielle Hunter
Vikings · LSU · DE
Rd 3pick #88
329% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 7 yrs starting
140 pts vs 43 expected
A
2016
Javon Hargrave
Steelers · South Carolina St. · DT
Rd 3pick #89
328% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 9 yrs starting
140 pts vs 43 expected
A
2001
Ryan Pickett
Rams · Ohio St. · DT
Rd 1pick #29
214% HIT
13 yrs starting
182 pts vs 85 expected
A
2012
Chandler Jones
Patriots · Syracuse · DE
Rd 1pick #21
201% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 10 yrs starting
187 pts vs 93 expected
A
2017
Myles Garrett
Browns · Texas A&M · DE
Rd 1pick #1
165% HIT
7 Pro Bowls · 5 All-Pro · 9 yrs starting
232 pts vs 141 expected
B
2003
Cory Redding
Lions · Texas · DE
Rd 3pick #66
253% HIT
10 yrs starting
147 pts vs 58 expected
A
2010
Corey Peters
Falcons · Kentucky · DT
Rd 3pick #83
305% HIT
9 yrs starting
131 pts vs 43 expected
A
2001
Casey Hampton
Steelers · Texas · NT
Rd 1pick #19
190% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 11 yrs starting
183 pts vs 96 expected
B
2005
Jonathan Babineaux
Falcons · Iowa · DE
Rd 2pick #59
244% HIT
10 yrs starting
146 pts vs 60 expected
A
2010
Jason Pierre-Paul
Giants · South Florida · DE
Rd 1pick #15
186% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
186 pts vs 100 expected
B
2000
Fred Robbins
Vikings · Wake Forest · DT
Rd 2pick #55
242% HIT
10 yrs starting
145 pts vs 60 expected
A
2004
Randy Starks
Titans · Maryland · DT
Rd 3pick #71
259% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 8 yrs starting
139 pts vs 53 expected
A
2016
Maliek Collins
Cowboys · Nebraska · DT
Rd 3pick #67
241% HIT
10 yrs starting
139 pts vs 58 expected
A
2005
Justin Tuck
Giants · Notre Dame · DE
Rd 3pick #74
260% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 7 yrs starting
131 pts vs 50 expected
A
2001
Shaun Rogers
Lions · Texas · DT
Rd 2pick #61
232% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 8 yrs starting
139 pts vs 60 expected
A
2013
Johnathan Hankins
Giants · Ohio St. · DT
Rd 2pick #49
223% HIT
10 yrs starting
142 pts vs 64 expected
A
2006
Tamba Hali
Chiefs · Penn St. · DE
Rd 1pick #20
181% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 10 yrs starting
174 pts vs 96 expected
B
2013
Brandon Williams
Ravens · Missouri Southern · DT
Rd 3pick #94
282% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 8 yrs starting
118 pts vs 42 expected
A
2007
Charles Johnson
Panthers · Georgia · DE
Rd 3pick #83
270% HIT
8 yrs starting
116 pts vs 43 expected
A
2010
Carlos Dunlap
Bengals · Florida · DE
Rd 2pick #54
219% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 7 yrs starting
131 pts vs 60 expected
A
2012
Akiem Hicks
Saints · Regina · DE
Rd 3pick #89
266% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 7 yrs starting
113 pts vs 43 expected
A
2001
Kris Jenkins
Panthers · Maryland · DT
Rd 2pick #44
201% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 6 yrs starting
135 pts vs 67 expected
A
2017
Dalvin Tomlinson
Giants · Alabama · DT
Rd 2pick #55
211% HIT
9 yrs starting
127 pts vs 60 expected
A
2014
DeMarcus Lawrence
Cowboys · Boise St. · DE
Rd 2pick #34
179% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 8 yrs starting
151 pts vs 85 expected
B
2003
Osi Umenyiora
Giants · Troy · DE
Rd 2pick #56
207% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 6 yrs starting
124 pts vs 60 expected
A
2009
Michael Johnson
Bengals · Georgia Tech · DE
Rd 3pick #70
217% HIT
8 yrs starting
119 pts vs 55 expected
A
2016
Yannick Ngakoue
Jaguars · Maryland · DE
Rd 3pick #69
214% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 8 yrs starting
120 pts vs 56 expected
A
2016
Kenny Clark
Packers · UCLA · DT
Rd 1pick #27
172% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 9 yrs starting
149 pts vs 86 expected
B
2010
Jerry Hughes
Colts · TCU · DE
Rd 1pick #31
173% HIT
9 yrs starting
146 pts vs 85 expected
B
2001
Kyle Vanden Bosch
Cardinals · Nebraska · DE
Rd 2pick #34
173% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 9 yrs starting
146 pts vs 85 expected
B
Showing 50 of 410

Best NFL draft picks: defensive line, ranked

Defensive line are the picks graded here. Each is compared with what the same draft slot usually produces: a pick that returns 40% or less of that counts as a bust at the default line, and 150% or more counts as a hit. Players drafted since 2022 are left off the ranking, because a young career has not had time to prove or disprove the pick.

Defensive line against the rest of the draft

Of 498 defensive line drafted in rounds 1–3 from 2000 to 2025, 17% were hits and 34% were busts at the 40% line, against 19% and 30% for all positions. Defensive line bust more often than the league as a whole.

RoundPicksHit rateBust rateValue vs slot
Round 118514%24%89%
Round 214415%40%85%
Round 316922%39%92%

Which teams draft defensive line best

With at least eight defensive line picks, the Steelers (158% of slot value, 11 picks), Cardinals (118% of slot value, 19 picks) and Bengals (117% of slot value, 15 picks) have gotten the most from the position. The Packers (43%, 15 picks), Bears (52%, 16 picks) and Falcons (63%, 15 picks) have gotten the least.

Looking at the other side? See the defensive line busts. Each player links to a page with the full pick-by-pick grade, and team grades and GM grades roll these picks up.

More NFL draft lists

Best picks by position

Biggest busts by position

Every list re-grades at the bust line you set. Back to the homepage, or see every draft class and how the grades work.