Grades / GM grades
General managers · every GM graded

NFL general managers ranked by draft grade

Every NFL general manager with enough graded picks, ranked on how their 2000–2025 first-three-round picks turned out against their draft slots, at a 40% bust line. John Dorsey (Chiefs) ranks first with an A and 43% hits; Ruston Webster (Titans) ranks #93. Move the bust line below and every GM re-ranks.

#
General manager
Hits · busts
Trend
Signature picks
Grade
1
John Dorsey
Chiefs · 2013–2017
43% hit14% bust
A
2
Tim Ruskell
Seahawks · 2005–2009
38% hit15% bust
A
3
Terry Bradway
Jets · 2001–2005
29% hit14% bust
A
4
Doug Whaley
Bills · 2013–2017
33% hit20% bust
A
5
Tom Donahoe
Bills · 2001–2005
29% hit18% bust
A
6
Shack Harris
Jaguars · 2003–2008
39% hit28% bust
A
7
Rich McKay
Falcons · 2003–2007
31% hit23% bust
A
8
Dave Gettleman
Panthers · 2013–2017
21% hit14% bust
A
9
Ozzie Newsome
Ravens · 2000–2018
32% hit25% bust
A
10
Kevin Colbert
Steelers · 2000–2021
27% hit22% bust
B
11
Martin Mayhew
Lions · 2009–2015
35% hit30% bust
B
12
David Caldwell
Jaguars · 2013–2020
22% hit19% bust
B
13
Jerry Jones
Cowboys · 2000–2025
27% hit24% bust
B
14
Rod Graves
Cardinals · 2000–2012
29% hit26% bust
B
15
Ernie Accorsi
Giants · 2000–2006
39% hit39% bust
B
16
Bruce Allen
Commanders · 2010–2019
27% hit27% bust
B
17
Mike Holmgren
Seahawks · 2000–2002
33% hit33% bust
–
B
18
A.J. Smith
Chargers · 2003–2012
23% hit23% bust
B
19
Scott Pioli
Chiefs · 2009–2012
14% hit14% bust
B
20
Butch Davis
Browns · 2001–2004
9% hit9% bust
B
21
Bob Quinn
Lions · 2016–2020
25% hit25% bust
B
22
Marty Hurney
Panthers · 2002–2012
30% hit32% bust
B
23
Bill Polian
Colts · 2000–2011
28% hit31% bust
B
24
Carl Peterson
Chiefs · 2000–2008
26% hit30% bust
B
25
Howie Roseman
Eagles · 2016–2025
15% hit19% bust
B
26
Brandon Beane
Bills · 2018–2025
21% hit25% bust
B
27
Mickey Loomis
Saints · 2002–2025
22% hit26% bust
B
28
Rick Spielman
Vikings · 2006–2021
22% hit26% bust
B
29
Ted Thompson
Packers · 2005–2017
26% hit31% bust
C
30
Mike Tannenbaum
Jets · 2006–2012
22% hit28% bust
C
31
John Schneider
Seahawks · 2010–2025
27% hit33% bust
C
32
Mike Reinfeldt
Titans · 2007–2011
25% hit31% bust
C
33
Ryan Pace
Bears · 2015–2021
13% hit19% bust
C
34
Tom Telesco
Chargers · 2013–2023
13% hit19% bust
C
35
Les Snead
Rams · 2012–2025
14% hit21% bust
C
36
Mark Dominik
Buccaneers · 2009–2013
21% hit29% bust
C
37
Jason Licht
Buccaneers · 2014–2025
17% hit24% bust
C
38
Al Davis
Raiders · 2000–2011
10% hit18% bust
C
39
Rick Smith
Texans · 2006–2017
24% hit32% bust
C
40
Eric DeCosta
Ravens · 2019–2025
4% hit12% bust
C
41
John Dorsey
Browns · 2017–2019
17% hit25% bust
–
C
42
Billy Devaney
Rams · 2008–2011
17% hit25% bust
C
43
Charley Armey
Rams · 2000–2005
19% hit29% bust
C
44
Tom Coughlin
Jaguars · 2000–2002
20% hit30% bust
–
C
45
Jerry Angelo
Bears · 2002–2011
24% hit34% bust
C
46
Steve Keim
Cardinals · 2013–2022
24% hit34% bust
C
47
Thomas Dimitroff
Falcons · 2008–2020
14% hit24% bust
C
48
Phil Savage
Browns · 2005–2008
22% hit33% bust
–
C
49
Buddy Nix
Bills · 2010–2012
11% hit22% bust
–
C
50
Nick Caserio
Texans · 2021–2025
6% hit17% bust
C
51
Mike Brown
Bengals · 2000–2025
22% hit33% bust
C
52
Jon Robinson
Titans · 2016–2022
20% hit32% bust
C
53
Howie Roseman
Eagles · 2010–2014
19% hit31% bust
C
54
Reggie McKenzie
Raiders · 2012–2017
19% hit31% bust
C
55
Chris Grier
Dolphins · 2016–2025
10% hit23% bust
C
56
Trent Baalke
Jaguars · 2021–2024
0% hit13% bust
C
57
Terry Donahue
49ers · 2000–2003
14% hit29% bust
C
58
Charley Casserly
Texans · 2002–2005
14% hit29% bust
C
59
Jeff Ireland
Dolphins · 2008–2013
19% hit33% bust
C
60
Matt Millen
Lions · 2001–2008
21% hit36% bust
C
61
Chris Ballard
Colts · 2017–2025
17% hit33% bust
C
62
Tom Heckert
Browns · 2010–2012
25% hit42% bust
–
C
63
Floyd Reese
Titans · 2000–2006
14% hit32% bust
C
64
Gene Smith
Jaguars · 2009–2012
18% hit36% bust
C
65
Bruce Allen
Buccaneers · 2004–2008
13% hit31% bust
C
66
Ryan Grigson
Colts · 2012–2016
14% hit36% bust
D
67
Vinny Cerrato
Commanders · 2000–2009
13% hit35% bust
D
68
John Elway
Broncos · 2011–2020
11% hit33% bust
D
69
Bill Belichick
Patriots · 2000–2023
20% hit43% bust
D
70
Brett Veach
Chiefs · 2018–2025
12% hit36% bust
D
71
Jerry Reese
Giants · 2007–2017
11% hit37% bust
D
72
Brad Holmes
Lions · 2021–2025
5% hit32% bust
D
73
Mike Maccagnan
Jets · 2015–2018
9% hit36% bust
D
74
Dave Gettleman
Giants · 2018–2021
7% hit36% bust
D
75
Monti Ossenfort
Cardinals · 2023–2025
7% hit36% bust
–
D
76
Trent Baalke
49ers · 2010–2016
8% hit38% bust
D
77
Ray Farmer
Browns · 2014–2015
10% hit40% bust
–
D
78
Omar Khan
Steelers · 2022–2025
0% hit31% bust
D
79
Brian Gutekunst
Packers · 2018–2025
0% hit31% bust
D
80
Andrew Berry
Browns · 2020–2025
5% hit37% bust
D
81
Marty Hurney
Panthers · 2018–2020
11% hit44% bust
–
D
82
Scott Fitterer
Panthers · 2021–2023
0% hit33% bust
–
D
83
George Paton
Broncos · 2021–2025
7% hit40% bust
D
84
Martin Mayhew
Commanders · 2020–2023
8% hit42% bust
D
85
Joe Schoen
Giants · 2022–2025
0% hit36% bust
F
86
Joe Douglas
Jets · 2019–2025
0% hit36% bust
F
87
John Lynch
49ers · 2017–2025
7% hit47% bust
F
88
Kwesi Adofo-Mensah
Vikings · 2022–2025
0% hit40% bust
F
89
Terry Fontenot
Falcons · 2021–2025
0% hit41% bust
F
90
Mike Sherman
Packers · 2001–2004
8% hit50% bust
F
91
Ryan Poles
Bears · 2022–2025
0% hit43% bust
F
92
Mike Mayock
Raiders · 2019–2021
0% hit46% bust
–
F
93
Ruston Webster
Titans · 2012–2015
0% hit50% bust
F

NFL general managers ranked by draft grade

93 general managers have enough graded picks to be ranked, and each is credited with the drafts they ran. The average hit rate is 17%. Letter grades come from rank, so the top tenth earn an A and the bottom tenth an F.

The top five

  1. John Dorsey (Chiefs, 2013–2017): an A, 43% hits and 14% busts on 14 picks
  2. Tim Ruskell (Seahawks, 2005–2009): an A, 38% hits and 15% busts on 13 picks
  3. Terry Bradway (Jets, 2001–2005): an A, 29% hits and 14% busts on 14 picks
  4. Doug Whaley (Bills, 2013–2017): an A, 33% hits and 20% busts on 15 picks
  5. Tom Donahoe (Bills, 2001–2005): an A, 29% hits and 18% busts on 17 picks

The bottom five

  1. Ruston Webster (Titans, 2012–2015): an F, 0% hits and 50% busts on 12 picks
  2. Mike Mayock (Raiders, 2019–2021): an F, 0% hits and 46% busts on 13 picks
  3. Ryan Poles (Bears, 2022–2025): an F, 0% hits and 43% busts on 14 picks
  4. Mike Sherman (Packers, 2001–2004): an F, 8% hits and 50% busts on 12 picks
  5. Terry Fontenot (Falcons, 2021–2025): an F, 0% hits and 41% busts on 17 picks

Among GMs with at least 25 graded picks, Ozzie Newsome (Ravens, 2000–2018) has the highest hit rate at 32%.

Ranks need a minimum number of picks, so a GM with one or two drafts may not appear until you widen the rounds or years. See team grades for the franchises, or the biggest steals and busts behind these grades.

More NFL draft lists

Best picks by position

Biggest busts by position

Every list re-grades at the bust line you set. Back to the homepage, or see every draft class and how the grades work.