Grades / TE busts
Tight ends · worst value for the slot

Biggest NFL draft busts: tight ends

The tight ends who fell furthest short of their draft slot. Every 2000–2025 first-three-round pick is scored against what its slot usually produces, and Bennie Joppru (TE, Texans, 41st overall in 2003) is the biggest miss at 7% of slot value. At the default 40% bust line, 22% of tight ends count as busts. Move the line below and the list re-ranks.

Year
Player
Pick
Value vs slot
Career
Grade
2003
Bennie Joppru
Texans · Michigan · TE
Rd 2pick #41
7% BUST
19 games played
5 pts vs 68 expected
F
2014
Jace Amaro
Jets · Texas Tech · TE
Rd 2pick #49
7% BUST
17 games played
4 pts vs 64 expected
F
2001
Sean Brewer
Bengals · San Jose St. · TE
Rd 3pick #66
5% BUST
12 games played
3 pts vs 58 expected
F
2018
Hayden Hurst
Ravens · South Carolina · TE
Rd 1pick #25
37% BUST
1 yr starting
32 pts vs 86 expected
D
2003
Teyo Johnson
Raiders · Stanford · TE
Rd 2pick #63
13% BUST
30 games played
8 pts vs 60 expected
F
2009
Richard Quinn
Broncos · North Carolina · TE
Rd 2pick #64
13% BUST
30 games played
8 pts vs 59 expected
F
2013
Gavin Escobar
Cowboys · San Diego St. · TE
Rd 2pick #47
24% BUST
64 games played
16 pts vs 66 expected
D
2019
Irv Smith Jr.
Vikings · Alabama · TE
Rd 2pick #50
22% BUST
54 games played
14 pts vs 62 expected
D
2013
Tyler Eifert
Bengals · Notre Dame · TE
Rd 1pick #21
48% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 2 yrs starting
45 pts vs 93 expected
C
2019
Jace Sternberger
Packers · Texas A&M · TE
Rd 3pick #75
9% BUST
18 games played
5 pts vs 49 expected
F
2014
Austin Seferian-Jenkins
Buccaneers · Washington · TE
Rd 2pick #38
41% FAIR
2 yrs starting
31 pts vs 75 expected
C
2017
Adam Shaheen
Bears · Ashland · TE
Rd 2pick #45
35% BUST
1 yr starting
24 pts vs 67 expected
D
2014
Eric Ebron
Lions · North Carolina · TE
Rd 1pick #10
63% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 4 yrs starting
73 pts vs 116 expected
C
2004
Kellen Winslow
Browns · Miami (FL) · TE
Rd 1pick #6
66% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 5 yrs starting
82 pts vs 124 expected
C
2012
Michael Egnew
Dolphins · Missouri · TE
Rd 3pick #78
10% BUST
18 games played
5 pts vs 46 expected
F
2019
Kahale Warring
Texans · San Diego St. · TE
Rd 3pick #86
5% BUST
9 games played
2 pts vs 43 expected
F
2021
Kyle Pitts
Falcons · Florida · TE
Rd 1pick #4
66% FAIR
1 Pro Bowl · 5 yrs starting
77 pts vs 118 expected
C
2019
T.J. Hockenson
Lions · Iowa · TE
Rd 1pick #8
66% FAIR
2 Pro Bowls · 4 yrs starting
78 pts vs 118 expected
C
2014
Troy Niklas
Cardinals · Notre Dame · TE
Rd 2pick #52
33% BUST
1 yr starting
20 pts vs 61 expected
D
2005
Kevin Everett
Bills · Miami (FL) · TE
Rd 3pick #86
10% BUST
17 games played
4 pts vs 43 expected
F
2017
O.J. Howard
Buccaneers · Alabama · TE
Rd 1pick #19
60% FAIR
4 yrs starting
58 pts vs 96 expected
C
2006
Dominique Byrd
Rams · USC · TE
Rd 3pick #93
10% BUST
17 games played
4 pts vs 42 expected
F
2008
Dustin Keller
Jets · Purdue · TE
Rd 1pick #30
57% FAIR
3 yrs starting
48 pts vs 85 expected
C
2003
Mike Seidman
Panthers · UCLA · TE
Rd 3pick #76
23% BUST
43 games played
11 pts vs 48 expected
D
2020
Devin Asiasi
Patriots · UCLA · TE
Rd 3pick #91
13% BUST
22 games played
6 pts vs 42 expected
F
2020
Dalton Keene
Patriots · Virginia Tech · TE
Rd 3pick #101
5% BUST
7 games played
2 pts vs 38 expected
F
2002
Jerramy Stevens
Seahawks · Washington · TE
Rd 1pick #28
59% FAIR
2 yrs starting
50 pts vs 86 expected
C
2004
Ben Troupe
Titans · Florida · TE
Rd 2pick #40
50% FAIR
2 yrs starting
34 pts vs 69 expected
C
2015
Clive Walford
Raiders · Miami (FL) · TE
Rd 3pick #68
40% FAIR
1 yr starting
23 pts vs 57 expected
C
2008
Brad Cottam
Chiefs · Tennessee · TE
Rd 3pick #76
34% BUST
1 yr starting
16 pts vs 48 expected
D
2009
Chase Coffman
Bengals · Missouri · TE
Rd 3pick #98
25% BUST
39 games played
10 pts vs 40 expected
D
2001
Shad Meier
Titans · Kansas St. · TE
Rd 3pick #90
31% BUST
53 games played
13 pts vs 42 expected
D
2021
Tre' McKitty
Chargers · Georgia · TE
Rd 3pick #97
23% BUST
34 games played
9 pts vs 37 expected
D
2021
Hunter Long
Dolphins · Boston Col. · TE
Rd 3pick #81
31% BUST
50 games played
13 pts vs 40 expected
D
2009
Travis Beckum
Giants · Wisconsin · TE
Rd 3pick #100
31% BUST
48 games played
12 pts vs 39 expected
D
2014
C.J. Fiedorowicz
Texans · Iowa · TE
Rd 3pick #65
56% FAIR
2 yrs starting
33 pts vs 59 expected
C
2006
Joe Klopfenstein
Rams · Colorado · TE
Rd 2pick #46
63% FAIR
3 yrs starting
42 pts vs 67 expected
C
2002
Matt Schobel
Bengals · TCU · TE
Rd 3pick #67
60% FAIR
1 yr starting
35 pts vs 58 expected
C
2012
Coby Fleener
Colts · Stanford · TE
Rd 2pick #34
73% FAIR
4 yrs starting
62 pts vs 85 expected
C
2020
Josiah Deguara
Packers · Cincinnati · TE
Rd 3pick #94
47% FAIR
78 games played
20 pts vs 42 expected
C
2014
Crockett Gillmore
Ravens · Colorado St. · TE
Rd 3pick #99
46% FAIR
1 yr starting
18 pts vs 39 expected
C
2002
Doug Jolley
Raiders · BYU · TE
Rd 2pick #55
64% FAIR
2 yrs starting
39 pts vs 60 expected
C
2015
Maxx Williams
Ravens · Minnesota · TE
Rd 2pick #55
68% FAIR
2 yrs starting
41 pts vs 60 expected
C
2000
Dustin Lyman
Bears · Wake Forest · TE
Rd 3pick #87
56% FAIR
1 yr starting
24 pts vs 43 expected
C
2019
Noah Fant
Broncos · Iowa · TE
Rd 1pick #20
82% FAIR
5 yrs starting
79 pts vs 96 expected
C
2008
Fred Davis
Commanders · USC · TE
Rd 2pick #48
74% FAIR
3 yrs starting
48 pts vs 65 expected
C
2004
Kris Wilson
Chiefs · Pittsburgh · TE
Rd 2pick #61
74% FAIR
2 yrs starting
44 pts vs 60 expected
C
2018
Mike Gesicki
Dolphins · Penn St. · TE
Rd 2pick #42
80% FAIR
2 yrs starting
54 pts vs 67 expected
C
2021
Pat Freiermuth
Steelers · Penn St. · TE
Rd 2pick #55
75% FAIR
2 yrs starting
41 pts vs 55 expected
C
2006
Tony Scheffler
Broncos · Western Michigan · TE
Rd 2pick #61
78% FAIR
2 yrs starting
47 pts vs 60 expected
C
Showing 50 of 113

Biggest NFL draft busts: tight ends, ranked

Tight ends are the picks graded here. Each is compared with what the same draft slot usually produces: a pick that returns 40% or less of that counts as a bust at the default line, and 150% or more counts as a hit. Players drafted since 2022 are left off the ranking, because a young career has not had time to prove or disprove the pick.

Tight ends against the rest of the draft

Of 135 tight ends drafted in rounds 1–3 from 2000 to 2025, 23% were hits and 22% were busts at the 40% line, against 19% and 30% for all positions. Tight ends bust less often than the league as a whole.

RoundPicksHit rateBust rateValue vs slot
Round 12928%3%113%
Round 24518%24%99%
Round 36125%30%121%

Looking at the other side? See the best tes. Each player links to a page with the full pick-by-pick grade, and team grades and GM grades roll these picks up.

More NFL draft lists

Best picks by position

Biggest busts by position

Every list re-grades at the bust line you set. Back to the homepage, or see every draft class and how the grades work.