Grades / Best defensive backs
Defensive backs · best value for the slot

Best NFL draft picks: defensive backs

The defensive backs who did the most with their draft slot. Every 2000–2025 first-three-round pick is scored against what its slot usually produces, and Ed Reed (DB, Ravens, 24th overall in 2002) leads at 344% of slot value. Set your own bust line and rounds below and the list re-ranks.

Year
Player
Pick
Value vs slot
Career
Grade
2002
Ed Reed
Ravens · Miami (FL) · DB
Rd 1pick #24
344% HIT
9 Pro Bowls · 5 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
298 pts vs 86 expected
A
2003
Troy Polamalu
Steelers · USC · DB
Rd 1pick #16
275% HIT
8 Pro Bowls · 4 All-Pro · 10 yrs starting
266 pts vs 97 expected
A
2013
Tyrann Mathieu
Cardinals · LSU · DB
Rd 3pick #69
374% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
209 pts vs 56 expected
A
2007
Eric Weddle
Chargers · Utah · DB
Rd 2pick #37
293% HIT
6 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 12 yrs starting
230 pts vs 79 expected
A
2012
Harrison Smith
Vikings · Notre Dame · DB
Rd 1pick #29
272% HIT
6 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 13 yrs starting
231 pts vs 85 expected
A
2007
Darrelle Revis
Jets · Pittsburgh · DB
Rd 1pick #14
232% HIT
7 Pro Bowls · 4 All-Pro · 9 yrs starting
246 pts vs 106 expected
A
2011
Patrick Peterson
Cardinals · LSU · DB
Rd 1pick #5
210% HIT
8 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 13 yrs starting
264 pts vs 126 expected
A
2001
Adrian Wilson
Cardinals · North Carolina St. · DB
Rd 3pick #64
333% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
197 pts vs 59 expected
A
2013
Darius Slay
Lions · Mississippi St. · DB
Rd 2pick #36
265% HIT
6 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 12 yrs starting
215 pts vs 81 expected
A
2006
Johnathan Joseph
Bengals · South Carolina · DB
Rd 1pick #24
249% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 15 yrs starting
215 pts vs 86 expected
A
2016
Kevin Byard
Titans · Middle Tenn. St. · S
Rd 3pick #64
315% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 9 yrs starting
187 pts vs 59 expected
A
2017
Budda Baker
Cardinals · Washington · S
Rd 2pick #36
232% HIT
8 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 8 yrs starting
188 pts vs 81 expected
A
2010
Devin McCourty
Patriots · Rutgers · DB
Rd 1pick #27
224% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 13 yrs starting
193 pts vs 86 expected
A
2012
Stephon Gilmore
Bills · South Carolina · DB
Rd 1pick #10
189% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 12 yrs starting
219 pts vs 116 expected
B
2003
Rashean Mathis
Jaguars · Bethune-Cookman · DB
Rd 2pick #39
240% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 1 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
172 pts vs 72 expected
A
2006
Devin Hester
Bears · Miami (FL) · DB
Rd 2pick #57
265% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 3 yrs starting
159 pts vs 60 expected
A
2016
Jalen Ramsey
Jaguars · Florida St. · CB
Rd 1pick #5
177% HIT
8 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 10 yrs starting
224 pts vs 126 expected
B
2010
Earl Thomas
Seahawks · Texas · DB
Rd 1pick #14
191% HIT
7 Pro Bowls · 3 All-Pro · 9 yrs starting
203 pts vs 106 expected
B
2003
Charles Tillman
Bears · Louisiana · DB
Rd 2pick #35
210% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 11 yrs starting
176 pts vs 84 expected
A
2003
Terence Newman
Cowboys · Kansas St. · DB
Rd 1pick #5
172% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 15 yrs starting
217 pts vs 126 expected
B
2016
Justin Simmons
Broncos · Boston Col. · S
Rd 3pick #98
314% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 8 yrs starting
126 pts vs 40 expected
A
2000
Deon Grant
Panthers · Tennessee · DB
Rd 2pick #57
240% HIT
10 yrs starting
144 pts vs 60 expected
A
2009
Malcolm Jenkins
Saints · Ohio St. · DB
Rd 1pick #14
177% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 12 yrs starting
188 pts vs 106 expected
B
2003
Nnamdi Asomugha
Raiders · California · DB
Rd 1pick #31
191% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 8 yrs starting
161 pts vs 85 expected
B
2002
Chris Hope
Steelers · Florida St. · DB
Rd 3pick #94
279% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 7 yrs starting
117 pts vs 42 expected
A
2010
Kareem Jackson
Texans · Alabama · DB
Rd 1pick #20
178% HIT
12 yrs starting
171 pts vs 96 expected
B
2007
Reggie Nelson
Jaguars · Florida · DB
Rd 1pick #21
180% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 11 yrs starting
167 pts vs 93 expected
B
2002
Sheldon Brown
Eagles · South Carolina · DB
Rd 2pick #59
223% HIT
9 yrs starting
134 pts vs 60 expected
A
2008
Aqib Talib
Buccaneers · Kansas · DB
Rd 1pick #20
175% HIT
5 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 9 yrs starting
169 pts vs 96 expected
B
2012
Jackrabbit Jenkins
Rams · North Alabama · DB
Rd 2pick #39
198% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 10 yrs starting
142 pts vs 72 expected
B
2001
Nate Clements
Bills · Ohio St. · DB
Rd 1pick #21
173% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 11 yrs starting
161 pts vs 93 expected
B
2017
Marlon Humphrey
Ravens · Alabama · CB
Rd 1pick #16
168% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 2 All-Pro · 8 yrs starting
163 pts vs 97 expected
B
2013
Logan Ryan
Patriots · Rutgers · DB
Rd 3pick #83
253% HIT
7 yrs starting
109 pts vs 43 expected
A
2003
Chris Crocker
Browns · Marshall · DB
Rd 3pick #84
253% HIT
7 yrs starting
108 pts vs 43 expected
A
2006
Roman Harper
Saints · Alabama · DB
Rd 2pick #43
195% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 8 yrs starting
131 pts vs 67 expected
B
2015
Steven Nelson
Chiefs · Oregon St. · CB
Rd 3pick #98
256% HIT
7 yrs starting
103 pts vs 40 expected
A
2018
Jessie Bates III
Bengals · Wake Forest · S
Rd 2pick #54
201% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 8 yrs starting
120 pts vs 60 expected
A
2006
Antonio Cromartie
Chargers · Florida St. · DB
Rd 1pick #19
163% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 8 yrs starting
157 pts vs 96 expected
B
2012
Casey Hayward
Packers · Vanderbilt · DB
Rd 2pick #62
200% HIT
2 Pro Bowls · 7 yrs starting
120 pts vs 60 expected
A
2019
Quincy Williams
Jaguars · Murray St. · S
Rd 3pick #98
244% HIT
1 All-Pro · 6 yrs starting
98 pts vs 40 expected
A
2013
Xavier Rhodes
Vikings · Florida St. · DB
Rd 1pick #25
166% HIT
3 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 8 yrs starting
144 pts vs 86 expected
B
2016
James Bradberry
Panthers · Samford · CB
Rd 2pick #62
196% HIT
1 Pro Bowl · 8 yrs starting
117 pts vs 60 expected
B
2016
Xavien Howard
Dolphins · Baylor · CB
Rd 2pick #38
176% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 7 yrs starting
132 pts vs 75 expected
B
2000
Greg Wesley
Chiefs · Ark-Pine Bluff · DB
Rd 3pick #85
234% HIT
7 yrs starting
100 pts vs 43 expected
A
2010
Morgan Burnett
Packers · Georgia Tech · DB
Rd 3pick #71
206% HIT
8 yrs starting
110 pts vs 53 expected
A
2018
Justin Reid
Texans · Stanford · S
Rd 3pick #68
196% HIT
8 yrs starting
112 pts vs 57 expected
B
2009
Sean Smith
Dolphins · Utah · DB
Rd 2pick #61
191% HIT
8 yrs starting
114 pts vs 60 expected
B
2011
Chris Conte
Bears · California · DB
Rd 3pick #93
229% HIT
7 yrs starting
96 pts vs 42 expected
A
2009
Patrick Chung
Patriots · Oregon · DB
Rd 2pick #34
164% HIT
10 yrs starting
138 pts vs 85 expected
B
2009
Jerraud Powers
Colts · Auburn · DB
Rd 3pick #92
226% HIT
7 yrs starting
95 pts vs 42 expected
A
Showing 50 of 443

Best NFL draft picks: defensive backs, ranked

Defensive backs are the picks graded here. Each is compared with what the same draft slot usually produces: a pick that returns 40% or less of that counts as a bust at the default line, and 150% or more counts as a hit. Players drafted since 2022 are left off the ranking, because a young career has not had time to prove or disprove the pick.

Defensive backs against the rest of the draft

Of 521 defensive backs drafted in rounds 1–3 from 2000 to 2025, 17% were hits and 29% were busts at the 40% line, against 19% and 30% for all positions. Defensive backs bust less often than the league as a whole.

RoundPicksHit rateBust rateValue vs slot
Round 114114%21%95%
Round 219018%23%95%
Round 319017%41%82%

Which teams draft defensive backs best

With at least eight defensive backs picks, the Cardinals (142% of slot value, 17 picks), Bears (129% of slot value, 13 picks) and Ravens (124% of slot value, 13 picks) have gotten the most from the position. The Raiders (64%, 20 picks), Vikings (66%, 19 picks) and Colts (70%, 22 picks) have gotten the least.

Looking at the other side? See the defensive back busts. Each player links to a page with the full pick-by-pick grade, and team grades and GM grades roll these picks up.

More NFL draft lists

Best picks by position

Biggest busts by position

Every list re-grades at the bust line you set. Back to the homepage, or see every draft class and how the grades work.