Grades / Team grades
Teams · every franchise graded

NFL teams ranked by draft grade

Every NFL franchise graded on how its 2000–2025 first-three-round picks turned out against their draft slots, at a 40% bust line. The Cowboys rank first (A, 27% hits) and the Broncos rank last (F, 39% busts). Move the bust line below and all 32 teams re-rank.

#
Team
Hits · busts
Trend
Signature picks
Grade
16
Colts
Indianapolis
21% hit33% bust
C
22
Rams
Los Angeles
14% hit29% bust
C
30
49ers
San Francisco
13% hit36% bust
F

NFL teams ranked by draft grade

The league average at this setting is a 19% hit rate and a 30% bust rate. Letter grades come from rank: the top 10% of teams get an A, the next 20% a B, the middle 40% a C, then D and F. The gap between first and last is 16% in hit rate, so the order is closer than the grades suggest in the middle of the pack.

Best draft team in each division

How much the bust line matters

at a 20% line the Cowboys rank first, at a 40% line the Cowboys rank first, at a 60% line the Cowboys rank first, at a 80% line the Cowboys rank first and at a 100% line the Cowboys rank first. The top spot does not change as the line moves.

See the general manager grades for the people behind these drafts, the biggest steals and biggest busts they made, or every draft class.

More NFL draft lists

Best picks by position

Biggest busts by position

Every list re-grades at the bust line you set. Back to the homepage, or see every draft class and how the grades work.