Teams / Colts
Team

Colts

Indianapolis · rank #14 of 32

C
DraftLedger grade
At a 40% bust line
Rounds 1–3 · 2000–2025 drafts. Change settings
80
Picks graded
21%
Hit rate
31%
Bust rate
92%
Value vs slot (100% = par)
By draft class
Grade for each year
A
C
C
B
C
C
B
F
A
C
C
D
B
D
C
D
D
D
C
C
A
B
B
F
B
D
0001020304050607080910111213141516171819202122232425

Each bar compares this class with the other 31 teams’ classes that same year.

The ledger
Every pick, scored against its slot
Year
Player
Pick
Pos
Value vs slot
Status
Grade
2025
Tyler Warren
Round 1 · Penn St.
#14
TE
81%
FAIR
C
2025
JT Tuimoloau
Round 2 · Ohio St.
#45
DE
30%
BUST
D
2025
Justin Walley
Round 3 · Minnesota
#80
CB
15%
BUST
F
2024
Laiatu Latu
Round 1 · UCLA
#15
DL
48%
FAIR
C
2024
Adonai Mitchell
Round 2 · Texas
#52
WR
75%
FAIR
C
2024
Matt Goncalves
Round 3 · Pittsburgh
#79
OL
107%
FAIR
C
2023
Anthony Richardson
Round 1 · Florida
#4
QB
19%
BUST
F
2023
Julius Brents
Round 2 · Kansas St.
#44
DB
15%
BUST
F
2023
Josh Downs
Round 3 · North Carolina
#79
WR
128%
FAIR
B
2022
Alec Pierce
Round 2 · Cincinnati
#53
WR
125%
FAIR
B
2022
Jelani Woods
Round 3 · Virginia
#73
TE
17%
BUST
F
2022
Bernhard Raimann
Round 3 · Central Michigan
#77
OL
163%
HIT
B
2022
Nick Cross
Round 3 · Maryland
#96
DB
121%
FAIR
C
2021
Kwity Paye
Round 1 · Michigan
#21
DL
83%
FAIR
C
2021
Dayo Odeyingbo
Round 2 · Vanderbilt
#54
DL
52%
FAIR
C
2020
Michael Pittman Jr.
Round 2 · USC
#34
WR
101%
FAIR
C
2020
Jonathan Taylor
Round 2 · Wisconsin
#41
RB
151%
HIT
B
2020
Julian Blackmon
Round 3 · Utah
#85
S
137%
FAIR
B
2019
Rock Ya-Sin
Round 2 · Temple
#34
CB
42%
FAIR
C
2019
Ben Banogu
Round 2 · TCU
#49
LB
20%
BUST
F
2019
Parris Campbell
Round 2 · Ohio St.
#59
WR
38%
BUST
D
2019
Bobby Okereke
Round 3 · Stanford
#89
LB
233%
HIT
A
2018
Quenton Nelson
Round 1 · Notre Dame
#6
G
162%
HIT
B
2018
Shaquille Leonard
Round 2 · South Carolina St.
#36
LB
152%
HIT
B
2018
Braden Smith
Round 2 · Auburn
#37
G
137%
FAIR
B
2018
Kemoko Turay
Round 2 · Rutgers
#52
OLB
17%
BUST
F
2018
Tyquan Lewis
Round 2 · Ohio St.
#64
DE
37%
BUST
D
2017
Malik Hooker
Round 1 · Ohio St.
#15
S
90%
FAIR
C
2017
Quincy Wilson
Round 2 · Florida
#46
CB
12%
BUST
F
2017
Tarell Basham
Round 3 · Ohio
#80
DE
69%
FAIR
C
2016
Ryan Kelly
Round 1 · Alabama
#18
C
152%
HIT
B
2016
T.J. Green
Round 2 · Clemson
#57
S
17%
BUST
F
2016
Le'Raven Clark
Round 3 · Texas Tech
#82
T
37%
BUST
D
2015
Phillip Dorsett
Round 1 · Miami (FL)
#29
WR
28%
BUST
D
2015
D'Joun Smith
Round 3 · Florida Atlantic
#65
CB
2%
BUST
F
2015
Henry Anderson
Round 3 · Stanford
#93
DE
148%
FAIR
B
2014
Jack Mewhort
Round 2 · Ohio St.
#59
T
86%
FAIR
C
2014
Donte Moncrief
Round 3 · Mississippi
#90
WR
120%
FAIR
C
2013
Bjoern Werner
Round 1 · Florida St.
#24
DE
23%
BUST
D
2013
Hugh Thornton
Round 3 · Illinois
#86
G
92%
FAIR
C
2012
Andrew Luck
Round 1 · Stanford
#1
QB
71%
FAIR
C
2012
Coby Fleener
Round 2 · Stanford
#34
TE
74%
FAIR
C
2012
Dwayne Allen
Round 3 · Clemson
#64
TE
104%
FAIR
C
2012
T.Y. Hilton
Round 3 · Florida International
#92
WR
334%
HIT
A
2011
Anthony Castonzo
Round 1 · Boston Col.
#22
T
153%
HIT
B
2011
Ben Ijalana
Round 2 · Villanova
#49
T
29%
BUST
D
2011
Drake Nevis
Round 3 · LSU
#87
DT
15%
BUST
F
2010
Jerry Hughes
Round 1 · TCU
#31
DE
175%
HIT
B
2010
Pat Angerer
Round 2 · Iowa
#63
LB
73%
FAIR
C
2010
Kevin Thomas
Round 3 · USC
#94
DB
5%
BUST
F
2009
Donald Brown
Round 1 · Connecticut
#27
RB
38%
BUST
D
2009
Fili Moala
Round 2 · USC
#56
DT
77%
FAIR
C
2009
Jerraud Powers
Round 3 · Auburn
#92
DB
226%
HIT
A
2008
Mike Pollak
Round 2 · Arizona St.
#59
T
67%
FAIR
C
2008
Philip Wheeler
Round 3 · Georgia Tech
#93
LB
150%
HIT
B
2007
Anthony Gonzalez
Round 1 · Ohio St.
#32
WR
24%
BUST
D
2007
Tony Ugoh
Round 2 · Arkansas
#42
T
45%
FAIR
C
2007
Dante Hughes
Round 3 · California
#95
DB
32%
BUST
D
2007
Quinn Pitcock
Round 3 · Ohio St.
#98
DT
6%
BUST
F
2006
Joseph Addai
Round 1 · LSU
#30
RB
78%
FAIR
C
2006
Tim Jennings
Round 2 · Georgia
#62
DB
178%
HIT
B
2006
Freddy Keiaho
Round 3 · San Diego St.
#94
LB
81%
FAIR
C
2005
Marlin Jackson
Round 1 · Michigan
#29
DB
40%
FAIR
C
2005
Kelvin Hayden
Round 2 · Illinois
#60
DB
109%
FAIR
C
2005
Vincent Burns
Round 3 · Kentucky
#92
DE
0%
BUST
F
2004
Bob Sanders
Round 2 · Iowa
#44
DB
102%
FAIR
C
2004
Ben Hartsock
Round 3 · Ohio St.
#68
TE
93%
FAIR
C
2004
Gilbert Gardner
Round 3 · Purdue
#69
LB
42%
FAIR
C
2003
Dallas Clark
Round 1 · Iowa
#24
TE
168%
HIT
B
2003
Mike Doss
Round 2 · Ohio St.
#58
DB
74%
FAIR
C
2003
Donald Strickland
Round 3 · Colorado
#90
DB
52%
FAIR
C
2002
Dwight Freeney
Round 1 · Syracuse
#11
DE
238%
HIT
A
2002
Larry Tripplett
Round 2 · Washington
#42
DT
94%
FAIR
C
2002
Joe Jefferson
Round 3 · Western Kentucky
#74
DB
13%
BUST
F
2001
Reggie Wayne
Round 1 · Miami (FL)
#30
WR
275%
HIT
A
2001
Idrees Bashir
Round 2 · Memphis
#37
DB
74%
FAIR
C
2001
Cory Bird
Round 3 · Virginia Tech
#91
DB
27%
BUST
D
2000
Rob Morris
Round 1 · BYU
#28
LB
76%
FAIR
C
2000
Marcus Washington
Round 2 · Auburn
#59
LB
199%
HIT
B
2000
David Macklin
Round 3 · Penn St.
#91
DB
166%
HIT
B
Takes on Colts
What fans are saying

Indianapolis Colts draft history, graded

At DraftLedger's default 40% bust line, the Colts grade C for their first-three-round picks from 2000 through 2025, ranking #14 of 32 teams. Of 80 picks, 21% were hits (at least 150% of what the slot usually produces) and 31% were busts. Move the bust line on the page above to see the ranking change.

Best picks for the slot: Dwight Freeney, Reggie Wayne, T.Y. Hilton, Quenton Nelson. Biggest misses: Bjoern Werner, Anthony Gonzalez, Phillip Dorsett, Anthony Richardson.

See every class on the NFL draft classes page, or how the grades work.