GMs / A.J. Smith
General manager

A.J. Smith

Chargers · 2003–2012 drafts · rank #17 of 93

B
DraftLedger grade
At a 40% bust line
Rounds 1–3 · 2000–2025 drafts. Change settings
31
Picks graded
23%
Hit rate
23%
Bust rate
104%
Value vs slot (100% = par)
By draft class
Grade for each year
C
B
B
C
C
C
C
B
C
D
03040506070809101112

Each bar compares this class with the other 31 teams’ classes that same year.

The ledger
Every pick, scored against its slot
Year
Player
Pick
Pos
Value vs slot
Status
Grade
2012
Melvin Ingram
Round 1 · South Carolina
#18
DE
120%
FAIR
C
2012
Kendall Reyes
Round 2 · Connecticut
#49
DT
77%
FAIR
C
2012
Brandon Taylor
Round 3 · LSU
#73
DB
2%
BUST
F
2011
Corey Liuget
Round 1 · Illinois
#18
DT
105%
FAIR
C
2011
Marcus Gilchrist
Round 2 · Clemson
#50
DB
148%
FAIR
B
2011
Jonas Mouton
Round 2 · Michigan
#61
LB
1%
BUST
F
2011
Vincent Brown
Round 3 · San Diego St.
#82
WR
45%
FAIR
C
2011
Shareece Wright
Round 3 · USC
#89
DB
101%
FAIR
C
2010
Ryan Mathews
Round 1 · Fresno St.
#12
RB
68%
FAIR
C
2010
Donald Butler
Round 3 · Washington
#79
LB
159%
HIT
B
2009
Larry English
Round 1 · Northern Illinois
#16
LB
27%
BUST
D
2009
Louis Vasquez
Round 3 · Texas Tech
#78
G
248%
HIT
A
2008
Antoine Cason
Round 1 · Arizona
#27
DB
79%
FAIR
C
2008
Jacob Hester
Round 3 · LSU
#69
FB
47%
FAIR
C
2007
Craig Davis
Round 1 · LSU
#30
WR
7%
BUST
F
2007
Eric Weddle
Round 2 · Utah
#37
DB
295%
HIT
A
2007
Anthony Waters
Round 3 · Clemson
#96
LB
12%
BUST
F
2006
Antonio Cromartie
Round 1 · Florida St.
#19
DB
163%
HIT
B
2006
Marcus McNeill
Round 2 · Auburn
#50
T
149%
FAIR
B
2006
Charlie Whitehurst
Round 3 · Clemson
#81
QB
14%
BUST
F
2005
Shawne Merriman
Round 1 · Maryland
#12
LB
78%
FAIR
C
2005
Luis Castillo
Round 1 · Northwestern
#28
DE
95%
FAIR
C
2005
Vincent Jackson
Round 2 · Northern Colorado
#61
WR
229%
HIT
A
2004
Eli Manning
Round 1 · Mississippi
#1
QB
165%
HIT
B
2004
Igor Olshansky
Round 2 · Oregon
#35
DE
119%
FAIR
C
2004
Nate Kaeding
Round 3 · Iowa
#65
K
90%
FAIR
C
2004
Nick Hardwick
Round 3 · Purdue
#66
C
224%
HIT
A
2003
Sammy Davis
Round 1 · Texas A&M
#30
DB
45%
FAIR
C
2003
Drayton Florence
Round 2 · Tuskegee
#46
DB
148%
FAIR
B
2003
Terrence Kiel
Round 2 · Texas A&M
#62
DB
75%
FAIR
C
2003
Courtney Van Buren
Round 3 · Ark-Pine Bluff
#80
T
27%
BUST
D
Takes on A.J. Smith
What fans are saying