Draft analysis · Data through the 2025 draft

How often NFL draft quarterbacks hit, round by round

Here is how 318 drafted quarterbacks from 2000 through 2025 actually turned out, by round and by where in round 1 they went.

Hit and bust rates by round

First-round quarterbacks bust 28.6% of the time, against 20.8% for all first-round picks. That makes them riskier than the average first-round pick.

RoundQuarterbacksHit rateBust rate
Round 17713.0%28.6%
Round 22516.0%48.0%
Round 33411.8%73.5%
Rounds 4 to 71827.7%81.3%

Does a higher pick mean a safer quarterback?

Among first-round quarterbacks the answer is mixed. Picks 1 to 5 bust 13.5% of the time, picks 6 to 15 45.0%, and picks 16 to 32 40.0%. Each group is small (37, 20, 20 quarterbacks), so a single player moves a rate by several points.

PicksQuarterbacksHit rateBust rate
1 to 53710.8%13.5%
6 to 152015.0%45.0%
16 to 322015.0%40.0%

The best quarterbacks drafted since 2000

By career ledger points, the best quarterbacks of the era are Tom Brady (round 6, #199), Aaron Rodgers and Drew Brees. The best quarterback taken after round 3 is Tom Brady, a round 6 pick at #199.

PlayerDraftPickTeamPro Bowls% of slot value
Tom Brady2000Round 6, #199Patriots152,759%
Aaron Rodgers2005Round 1, #24Packers10534%
Drew Brees2001Round 2, #32Chargers13480%
Matthew Stafford2009Round 1, #1Lions3205%
Matt Ryan2008Round 1, #3Falcons4214%
Philip Rivers2004Round 1, #4Giants8212%
Ben Roethlisberger2004Round 1, #11Steelers6233%
Patrick Mahomes2017Round 1, #10Chiefs6217%

The biggest first-round quarterback busts

These are the first-round quarterbacks through the 2023 class who returned the least of what their slot promised. Later classes are left out because quarterbacks need time.

PlayerDraftPickTeamGames% of slot value
Paxton Lynch2016#26Broncos51%
Trey Lance2021#349ers163%
Johnny Manziel2014#22Browns144%
Dwayne Haskins2019#15Commanders164%
Josh Rosen2018#10Cardinals2414%

See the full lists on the quarterback busts and best quarterbacks pages.

Grades and thresholds are explained on the method page. In this article a hit is a pick that returned at least 150% of what its slot usually produces, and a bust is a pick that returned less than 40% (the default bust line, which you can change on every table on the site).

More draft analysis

Grade any pick, team or GM at your own bust line on DraftLedger. DraftLedger is a StatsLedger product; see how careers played out in StatsLedger.