The ten biggest top-10 draft busts since 2000
A top-10 pick is supposed to be a franchise player. These ten are the ones who returned the least of what their slot promised, in the 240 top-10 picks from 2000 through 2023.
Ten worst top-10 picks since 2000
Of 240 top-10 picks, 38 (15.8%) busted under the default line. The ten below are the extreme end: none of them ever made a Pro Bowl, and the one who lasted longest, Dion Jordan, still played only 63 games. The newest classes are left out because players drafted in 2024 or later have not had time to prove anything.
| Player | Draft | Pick | Team | Pos | Games | % of slot value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charles Rogers | 2003 | #2 | Lions | WR | 15 | 3% |
| Trey Lance | 2021 | #3 | 49ers | QB | 16 | 3% |
| Jamal Reynolds | 2001 | #10 | Packers | DE | 18 | 4% |
| Kevin White | 2015 | #7 | Bears | WR | 30 | 6% |
| Justin Gilbert | 2014 | #8 | Browns | DB | 35 | 7% |
| Vernon Gholston | 2008 | #6 | Jets | DE | 45 | 9% |
| Justin Blackmon | 2012 | #5 | Jaguars | WR | 20 | 12% |
| Dion Jordan | 2013 | #3 | Dolphins | DE | 63 | 12% |
| Dee Milliner | 2013 | #9 | Jets | DB | 21 | 13% |
| Josh Rosen | 2018 | #10 | Cardinals | QB | 24 | 14% |
What they have in common
By position, the ten are 3 WR, 3 DE, 2 QB, and 2 DB. WR and DE lead the list with 3 each. A bust rate is not a character judgment: a pick who gets hurt in year two and never recovers scores the same as one who never earns a starting job.
The same list is available for every position and in every round on the biggest busts page, with a bust line you control. If you think 40% of slot value is too harsh or too forgiving, change it and the list reshuffles. Grades and thresholds are explained on the method page. In this article a hit is a pick that returned at least 150% of what its slot usually produces, and a bust is a pick that returned less than 40% (the default bust line, which you can change on every table on the site).
More draft analysis
- Round 1 picks bust less, and hit less, than any other round
- The best late-round picks since 2000, and how often they happen
- The best and worst drafting teams in the NFL since 2000
- Which colleges produce the best NFL draft picks
- How often NFL draft quarterbacks hit, round by round
- The best and worst NFL draft classes since 2000
- The odds a draft pick becomes a Pro Bowler, by pick number
- Late round 1 versus early round 2: which picks are worth more
- Which positions hit and bust most in the NFL draft
Grade any pick, team or GM at your own bust line on DraftLedger. DraftLedger is a StatsLedger product; see how careers played out in StatsLedger.