Draft analysis · Data through the 2025 draft

Round 1 picks bust less, and hit less, than any other round

Round 1 picks bust less often than any other round, and they also hit less often than any other round. That sounds backwards until you see how the grades are built. Here is what 827 first-round picks from 2000 through 2025 actually did.

Hit and bust rates by round

A pick is graded against what its slot usually produces, so the bar for a first-round pick is high and the bar for a seventh-round pick is low. That cuts both ways. Only 14.6% of first-rounders cleared 150% of their slot value, the lowest of any round, because a top-10 pick has to become a star to beat expectations by half. In round 4 the rate is 23.2%, because beating a modest expectation is much easier.

RoundPicksHit rateBust rate
182714.6%20.8%
282717.8%29.1%
393522.8%38.8%
495523.2%38.1%
595222.4%47.0%
61,02618.7%53.6%
71,12219.0%58.0%

The bust side moves the other way. Round 1 busts 20.8% of the time, and the rate climbs from there to 58.0% in round 7. One likely reason is playing time: a first-round pick gets a long leash and a real chance to play, while a late pick often never makes the roster.

Grades and thresholds are explained on the method page. In this article a hit is a pick that returned at least 150% of what its slot usually produces, and a bust is a pick that returned less than 40% (the default bust line, which you can change on every table on the site).

Which positions bust most in round 1

Among positions with at least 25 first-round picks, CB (39.4% bust rate, 33 picks), QB (28.6% bust rate, 77 picks), and DE (27.6% bust rate, 98 picks) bust most often. TE (3.4%, 29 picks) and T (14.1%, 78 picks) bust least. TE has the best hit rate of the group at 27.6%.

PositionPicksHit rateBust rate
CB336.1%39.4%
QB7713.0%28.6%
DE9816.3%27.6%
RB559.1%27.3%
WR10911.9%25.7%
DT7211.1%20.8%
DB9518.9%16.8%
OL310.0%16.1%
LB6720.9%14.9%
T7814.1%14.1%
TE2927.6%3.4%

Treat the smaller groups with care. Tight end has fewer than 30 first-round picks, so a couple of players move its rate several points. The quarterback number is the one that matters most to teams: 28.6% of first-round quarterbacks since 2000 returned less than 40% of what their slot predicts. See the full quarterback bust list and the best quarterbacks.

Does the pick number matter inside round 1?

It does, but not evenly. Picks 21 to 32 bust 27.0% of the time, against 13.8% for picks 1 to 5. The group with the fewest hits is picks 6 to 10 at 10.8%.

PicksCountHit rateBust rate
1 to 513015.4%13.8%
6 to 1013010.8%18.5%
11 to 2026014.2%18.1%
21 to 3230716.3%27.0%

The takeaway is to judge a first-round pick against his slot, not against the whole class: a #8 pick has to outproduce what the average #8 pick delivers to count as a hit. Browse every 2025 NFL Draft pick on its own page, or see the biggest busts and the biggest steals.

More draft analysis

Grade any pick, team or GM at your own bust line on DraftLedger. DraftLedger is a StatsLedger product; see how careers played out in StatsLedger.