Draft analysis · Data through the 2025 draft

The best and worst NFL draft classes since 2000

Some draft classes produce a wave of stars and some barely produce a starter. This ranks the 21 classes from 2000 through 2020 by how often their picks in rounds 1 to 3 hit.

The five best draft classes

The 2001 class tops the list: 33.7% of its 95 picks in rounds 1 to 3 hit and 24.2% busted.

ClassPicksHit rateBust rate
2001 draft9533.7%24.2%
2010 draft9833.7%25.5%
2003 draft9725.8%28.9%
2016 draft9825.5%30.6%
2012 draft9525.3%32.6%

The five weakest draft classes

The 2020 class is the weakest by hit rate, at 10.4%, with 34.9% of its picks busting.

ClassPicksHit rateBust rate
2020 draft10610.4%34.9%
2019 draft10213.7%27.5%
2015 draft9916.2%32.3%
2002 draft9817.3%25.5%
2008 draft9918.2%27.3%

Is the draft getting better or worse?

Split the classes into three eras and the hit rate moves like this:

EraPicksHit rateBust rate
2000 to 200667824.3%28.3%
2007 to 201368523.8%31.4%
2014 to 202071218.8%28.7%

Older classes have had longer to pile up games and honors, which lifts their hit rates, so comparing eras is not a clean test of whether teams are drafting better. Only classes with at least six seasons played (through 2020) are ranked here; newer classes are left out until they have had time. Every class has its own page with every pick graded: start at the list of draft classes.

Grades and thresholds are explained on the method page. In this article a hit is a pick that returned at least 150% of what its slot usually produces, and a bust is a pick that returned less than 40% (the default bust line, which you can change on every table on the site).

More draft analysis

Grade any pick, team or GM at your own bust line on DraftLedger. DraftLedger is a StatsLedger product; see how careers played out in StatsLedger.