Late round 1 versus early round 2: which picks are worth more
Teams that trade down from the end of round 1 into the start of round 2 are betting that the two spots are worth about the same. Here is how picks 21 to 32 and picks 33 to 44 actually compared for drafts from 2000 through 2022.
Late round 1 versus early round 2
Late first-round picks (276 players) hit 18.5% of the time and busted 27.5%. The first twelve picks of round 2 (276 players) hit 17.4% and busted 22.5%. So the late-first group busts more often than the early-second group, by 5.1 points, while its hit rate is higher by 1.1 points.
| Picks | Players | Hit rate | Bust rate | Pro Bowl | Started 5+ seasons | Return vs slot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Picks 21 to 32 (late round 1) | 276 | 18.5% | 27.5% | 30.4% | 45.3% | 95% |
| Picks 33 to 44 (early round 2) | 276 | 17.4% | 22.5% | 23.6% | 44.2% | 95% |
| Picks 45 to 64 (rest of round 2) | 460 | 22.0% | 32.0% | 19.3% | 32.4% | 97% |
What the gap means
The last column is the group's total career ledger points divided by what its slots usually produce. Both groups returned about 95% of slot value, so by this measure the two spots are close to equal. Late first-rounders made a Pro Bowl 30.4% of the time against 23.6% for early second-rounders, so the higher pick still carries a better chance at a star.
Two things the table cannot tell you. The late first round comes with a guaranteed fifth-year option and a higher salary, which changes the value to the team in ways these grades do not measure. And each group is a few hundred players, so a difference of a point or two is noise. See every team's best and worst picks on its team page, and the full busts and steals lists.
Grades and thresholds are explained on the method page. In this article a hit is a pick that returned at least 150% of what its slot usually produces, and a bust is a pick that returned less than 40% (the default bust line, which you can change on every table on the site).
More draft analysis
- Round 1 picks bust less, and hit less, than any other round
- The best late-round picks since 2000, and how often they happen
- The best and worst drafting teams in the NFL since 2000
- The ten biggest top-10 draft busts since 2000
- Which colleges produce the best NFL draft picks
- How often NFL draft quarterbacks hit, round by round
- The best and worst NFL draft classes since 2000
- The odds a draft pick becomes a Pro Bowler, by pick number
- Which positions hit and bust most in the NFL draft
Grade any pick, team or GM at your own bust line on DraftLedger. DraftLedger is a StatsLedger product; see how careers played out in StatsLedger.