Draft analysis · Data through the 2025 draft

The best and worst drafting teams in the NFL since 2000

Which NFL teams have drafted best since 2000, and which have been worst? This ranking uses every pick in rounds 1 through 3 from 2000 through 2025, each scored against what its slot usually produces.

The five best drafting teams

League-wide, 18.6% of picks in rounds 1 to 3 were hits and 30.0% were busts. The teams below rank highest on DraftLedger's team score. The Dallas Cowboys lead the league, with 26.7% of their 75 picks hitting and 24.0% busting.

RankTeamGradePicksHit rateBust rate
1Dallas CowboysA7526.7%24.0%
2Baltimore RavensA8523.5%21.2%
3Seattle SeahawksA8028.7%28.7%
4Pittsburgh SteelersB8022.5%23.8%
5Los Angeles ChargersB7819.2%20.5%

The fewest busts of any team belong to Los Angeles Chargers at 20.5%. The highest hit rate belongs to Seattle Seahawks at 28.7%. Among teams that bust more often than average, Arizona Cardinals hit most often: 23.5% hits against 30.6% busts, a boom-or-bust profile.

The five worst drafting teams

At the bottom, the Denver Broncos rank last. Only 10.2% of their picks hit, the lowest rate in the league, and 38.6% busted. The highest bust rate in the league belongs to New England Patriots at 41.6%.

RankTeamGradePicksHit rateBust rate
32Denver BroncosF8810.2%38.6%
31Cleveland BrownsF8812.5%36.4%
30San Francisco 49ersF8812.5%36.4%
29New England PatriotsD8918.0%41.6%
28New York GiantsD8114.8%37.0%

What the ranking does and does not say

Draft grades measure picks, not coaching, free agency or quarterback luck. A team can draft well and still lose, and a team can have a bad draft record and win with veterans acquired elsewhere. Rounds 1 to 3 are the default because those picks are the ones teams control; the team pages let you change the rounds, the bust line and the start year.

Grades and thresholds are explained on the method page. In this article a hit is a pick that returned at least 150% of what its slot usually produces, and a bust is a pick that returned less than 40% (the default bust line, which you can change on every table on the site).

See every team on the team draft grades page, or compare general managers on the GM grades page.

More draft analysis

Grade any pick, team or GM at your own bust line on DraftLedger. DraftLedger is a StatsLedger product; see how careers played out in StatsLedger.