Colleges / Baylor
College

Baylor

17 graded picks, 2000–2025 · rank #54 of 54

F
DraftLedger grade
At a 40% bust line

Baylor has a DraftLedger draft grade of F, ranking #54 of 54 colleges for first-through-third-round NFL draft picks from 2000 to 2025. 6% of its 17 graded picks were hits and 53% were busts at the default 40% bust line.

Rounds 1–3 · 2000–2025 drafts · bust below 40% Change settings
Bust line 40%
LenientStrict
Draft rounds
Drafts since
Or one draft
17
Picks graded
6%
Hit rate
53%
Bust rate
53%
Value vs slot (100% = par)
By draft class
Value for each draft class
0109101112131619202223

Each bar is the value that year’s picks returned against their slots. Green is at least 120% of par, red is under 80%. Years with no graded picks are skipped.

The ledger
Every pick, scored against its slot
Year
Player
Pick
Value vs slot
Career
Grade
2023
Siaki Ika
Browns · DL
Rd 3pick #98
4% BUST
4 games played
1 pts vs 23 expected
F
2022
Jalen Pitre
Texans · S
Rd 2pick #37
95% FAIR
4 yrs starting
56 pts vs 59 expected
C
2022
Tyquan Thornton
Patriots · WR
Rd 2pick #50
46% FAIR
1 yr starting
22 pts vs 47 expected
C
2022
JT Woods
Chargers · S
Rd 3pick #79
10% BUST
13 games played
3 pts vs 34 expected
F
2022
Terrel Bernard
Bills · LB
Rd 3pick #89
145% FAIR
3 yrs starting
46 pts vs 32 expected
B
2020
Denzel Mims
Jets · WR
Rd 2pick #59
29% BUST
1 yr starting
18 pts vs 60 expected
D
2019
Jalen Hurd
49ers · WR
Rd 3pick #67
0% BUST
Did not play
0 pts vs 58 expected
F
2016
Corey Coleman
Browns · WR
Rd 1pick #15
27% BUST
2 yrs starting
27 pts vs 100 expected
D
2016
Xavien Howard
Dolphins · CB
Rd 2pick #38
176% HIT
4 Pro Bowls · 1 All-Pro · 7 yrs starting
132 pts vs 75 expected
B
2013
Terrance Williams
Cowboys · WR
Rd 3pick #74
121% FAIR
4 yrs starting
61 pts vs 50 expected
C
2012
Robert Griffin III
Commanders · QB
Rd 1pick #2
37% BUST
1 Pro Bowl · 3 yrs starting
50 pts vs 136 expected
D
2012
Kendall Wright
Titans · WR
Rd 1pick #20
52% FAIR
3 yrs starting
51 pts vs 96 expected
C
2011
Phil Taylor
Browns · DT
Rd 1pick #21
33% BUST
2 yrs starting
31 pts vs 93 expected
D
2011
Danny Watkins
Eagles · G
Rd 1pick #23
19% BUST
1 yr starting
16 pts vs 86 expected
F
2010
J.D. Walton
Broncos · C
Rd 3pick #80
99% FAIR
3 yrs starting
44 pts vs 44 expected
C
2009
Jason Smith
Rams · T
Rd 1pick #2
23% BUST
2 yrs starting
31 pts vs 136 expected
D
2001
Gary Baxter
Ravens · DB
Rd 2pick #62
76% FAIR
3 yrs starting
46 pts vs 60 expected
C

Baylor in the NFL draft

At DraftLedger's default 40% bust line, Baylor grade F for first-three-round picks from 2000 through 2025, ranking #54 of 54 colleges; just above them is Clemson (F). Of 17 graded picks, 6% were hits (at least 150% of what the slot usually produces) and 53% were busts, below the 19% hit rate and above the 30% bust rate for all picks. Together they returned 53% of slot value, where 100% is par.

Counting every round, 48 players from Baylor have been drafted since 2000, including 29 picks in rounds 4–7 that DraftLedger does not grade. Colleges are ranked on value against slot rather than volume, so a school with fewer picks can outrank one that sends more players.

Draft capital

EraRound 1Rounds 2–3Rounds 4–7Total
2000–20091157
2010–2019541827
2020–202606814
Total6113148

Baylor have had 6 first-round picks since 2000, #46 among the 102 colleges that have produced one, or 1% of all first-rounders. 2 picks went in the top 10 and 2 in the top 5. The highest pick was Jason Smith, 2nd overall in 2009, and the most recent first-rounder is Corey Coleman (2016, 15th overall). The busiest stretch for first-round picks was 2010–2019, with 5.

Best picks and biggest misses

Most points over the slot
Most points below the slot

Which positions Baylor send to the NFL

PositionPicksHit rateBust rateValue vs slot
Wide receivers60%50%43%
Defensive backs425%25%104%
Offensive line30%67%34%
Defensive line20%100%28%
Quarterbacks10%100%37%
Linebackers10%0%145%

The most common position among Baylor' graded picks is wide receivers (6 of 17, 35%). With at least four picks, the best returns have come at defensive backs (104% of slot value) and the weakest at wide receivers (43%).

Round by round

RoundPicksHit rateBust rateValue vs slotLeague
Round 160%83%32%92%
Round 2520%20%91%94%
Round 360%50%64%94%

Baylor have gotten the most against the league in round 2 (91% of slot value, against 94% for all picks) and the least in round 1 (32% against 92%).

Which teams draft Baylor players

TeamPicksValue vs slot
Browns327%
Dolphins1176%
Bills1145%
Cowboys1121%
Broncos199%
Texans195%

The Browns have drafted the most Baylor players in rounds 1–3 (3), and 15 different teams have taken at least one.

Draft class by class

YearPicksValue vs slotHit rateBust rateHighest pick
202314%0%100%Siaki Ika (#98)
2022474%0%25%Jalen Pitre (#37)
2020129%0%100%Denzel Mims (#59)
201910%0%100%Jalen Hurd (#67)
2016291%50%50%Corey Coleman (#15)
20131121%0%0%Terrance Williams (#74)
2012243%0%50%Robert Griffin III (#2)
2011226%0%100%Phil Taylor (#21)
2010199%0%0%J.D. Walton (#80)
2009123%0%100%Jason Smith (#2)
2001176%0%0%Gary Baxter (#62)

The best Baylor class was 2016: 2 picks returned 91% of slot value, led by Corey Coleman. The weakest was 2011, at 26%. Value is up in recent years: 41% of slot value for 2000–2012 picks against 68% for 2013–2025.

Pro Bowls and All-Pros

Players drafted out of Baylor since 2000 have made 5 Pro Bowls and 1 first- or second-team All-Pro selection, from 2 different players. The leaders:

  1. Xavien Howard (CB, Dolphins, 2016 round 2): 4 Pro Bowls, 1 All-Pro, 7 seasons as a starter
  2. Robert Griffin III (QB, Commanders, 2012 round 1): 1 Pro Bowl, 3 seasons as a starter

Later-round picks

29 players from Baylor were taken in rounds 4–7 from 2000 to 2025. 1 of them became a Pro Bowler or a starter for five or more seasons:

The 2026 draft class

2 players from Baylor were taken in the 2026 NFL Draft. Rookies are not graded until they have played a season.

Colleges ranked near Baylor

Arkansas (#51, F), Central Florida (#52, F) and Clemson (#53, F). See the full college rankings, which re-rank at any bust line, or the best draft picks by position and the biggest busts.

Frequently asked questions

How many NFL first-round picks has Baylor produced since 2000?

Baylor has had 6 first-round picks in the NFL draft from 2000 through 2026, ranking #46 among colleges, with 2 in the top 10.

Who is the best draft pick from Baylor?

By value against draft slot, the best graded pick from Baylor is Xavien Howard (CB, Dolphins, 38th overall in 2016), who returned 176% of what the slot usually produces.

Who is the biggest draft bust from Baylor?

At DraftLedger's default 40% bust line, the biggest miss is Jason Smith (T, Rams, 2nd overall in 2009), who returned 23% of slot value.

What is Baylor's NFL draft grade?

Baylor grades F, ranking #54 of 54 colleges, for first-three-round picks from 2000 to 2025. 6% of its 17 graded picks were hits and 53% were busts, and the picks returned 53% of slot value. Grades change with the bust line you set.

Which NFL team has drafted the most Baylor players?

The Browns have drafted the most Baylor players in rounds 1–3 since 2000, with 3.