Drafts / 2008 / Carl Nicks
2008 draft · round 5 · pick #164

Carl Nicks

New Orleans Saints · T · Nebraska

A
At a 40% bust line
HIT

Carl Nicks (T, Nebraska) was the 164th overall pick (round 5) by the New Orleans Saints in the 2008 NFL Draft. The pick has returned 344% of what that slot usually produces, so DraftLedger rates it a hit at the default 40% bust line.

Graded at a 40% bust line Change settings
Bust line 40%
LenientStrict
Value vs slot
344% of what pick #164 usually produces
0%bust below 40%hit at 150%+300%+
The numbers
82Ledger points earned
24Expected for this slot
4Seasons as a starter
2Pro Bowls
1All-Pro selections
73Games played

How ledger points work

Takes on Carl Nicks
What fans are saying

Carl Nicks: 2008 NFL Draft, pick #164

With the 164th overall pick of the 2008 NFL Draft, the New Orleans Saints took T Carl Nicks of Nebraska. He has played 73 games, with 4 seasons as a starter, 2 Pro Bowl selections and 1 All-Pro selection. His 82 ledger points compare with about 24 that pick #164 usually produces, or 344% of par. That clears the 150% mark for a hit, so DraftLedger grades the pick a hit (A).

How pick #164 usually turns out

In the 1990–2019 drafts, 29 other players went 164th overall. They averaged 16 ledger points, 69% fell below the 40% bust line and 14% reached a hit.

Best from this slot
  • Dan Koppen (C, 2003, Patriots): 544% of par
  • Thomas Morstead (P, 2009, Saints): 435% of par
  • E.J. Speed (LB, 2019, Colts): 238% of par
Toughest from this slot
  • Omar Jacobs (QB, 2006, Steelers): 0% of par
  • Tim Scharf (LB, 1997, Jets): 0% of par
  • Gary Bandy (DE, 1996, Falcons): 0% of par

The 2008 draft and the Saints

Among the 153 picks in rounds 4–7 of the 2008 draft, Carl Nicks ranks 14th by value against slot. Among 18 T picks in those rounds he ranks 3rd. The Saints also drafted Sedrick Ellis (#7, DT), Tracy Porter (#40, DB) that year. The pick was made under Mickey Loomis, who ran the Saints’ drafts from 2002 to 2025.

A late-round pick who made it

Picks after round 3 rarely become long-term contributors. Of the 4,899 players taken in rounds 4–7 of the 1990–2019 drafts, 5% made at least one Pro Bowl and 9% started for five or more seasons. For round 5 alone, 73 of 1,035 reached a Pro Bowl and 110 started for five or more seasons. Carl Nicks made 2 Pro Bowls, which puts a round 5 pick in rare company. DraftLedger grades every round against its slot, and because late slots carry low expectations, a career like this finishes well above par.

Frequently asked questions

Was Carl Nicks a draft bust?

No. Carl Nicks has returned 344% of what the 164th pick usually produces (82 ledger points against about 24), compared with the 40% bust line and the 150% hit line. That grades the pick a hit (A).

Where was Carl Nicks drafted?

Carl Nicks (T, Nebraska) was taken 164th overall, in round 5, by the New Orleans Saints in the 2008 NFL Draft.

How does Carl Nicks compare with other No. 164 picks?

In the 1990–2019 drafts, 29 other players went 164th overall. They averaged 16 ledger points, 69% fell below the 40% bust line and 14% reached a hit. Carl Nicks returned 344% of par.

See the whole 2008 NFL Draft class, or nearby picks: #167 Erik Walden. How grades work.