Drafts / 2024
NFL Draft class

2024 NFL Draft: hits and busts

Every first-three-rounds pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, scored against what its slot usually produces at DraftLedger's default 40% bust line. 3 picks were hits and 28 were busts out of 100. Best pick for the slot: Calen Bullock. Biggest miss: J.J. McCarthy.

Round
Player
Pick
Pos
Value vs slot
Status
Grade
Rd 1
Caleb Williams
Bears · USC
#1
QB
52%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Jayden Daniels
Commanders · LSU
#2
QB
42%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Drake Maye
Patriots · North Carolina
#3
QB
78%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Marvin Harrison Jr.
Cardinals · Ohio St.
#4
WR
52%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Joe Alt
Chargers · Notre Dame
#5
OL
43%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Malik Nabers
Giants · LSU
#6
WR
44%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
JC Latham
Titans · Alabama
#7
OL
59%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Michael Penix
Falcons · Washington
#8
QB
30%
BUST
D
Rd 1
Rome Odunze
Bears · Washington
#9
WR
60%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
J.J. McCarthy
Vikings · Michigan
#10
QB
28%
BUST
D
Rd 1
Olu Fashanu
Jets · Penn St.
#11
OL
42%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Bo Nix
Broncos · Oregon
#12
QB
63%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Brock Bowers
Raiders · Georgia
#13
TE
91%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Taliese Fuaga
Saints · Oregon St.
#14
OL
66%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Laiatu Latu
Colts · UCLA
#15
DL
48%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Byron Murphy
Seahawks · Texas
#16
DL
49%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Dallas Turner
Vikings · Alabama
#17
LB
49%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Amarius Mims
Bengals · Georgia
#18
OL
74%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Jared Verse
Rams · Florida St.
#19
DL
106%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Troy Fautanu
Steelers · Washington
#20
OL
41%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Chop Robinson
Dolphins · Penn St.
#21
DE
24%
BUST
D
Rd 1
Quinyon Mitchell
Eagles · Toledo
#22
CB
129%
FAIR
B
Rd 1
Brian Thomas
Jaguars · LSU
#23
WR
99%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Terrion Arnold
Lions · Alabama
#24
DB
45%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Jordan Morgan
Packers · Arizona
#25
OL
49%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Graham Barton
Buccaneers · Duke
#26
OL
84%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Darius Robinson
Cardinals · Missouri
#27
DL
48%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Xavier Worthy
Chiefs · Texas
#28
WR
82%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Tyler Guyton
Cowboys · Oklahoma
#29
OL
80%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Nate Wiggins
Ravens · Clemson
#30
CB
57%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Ricky Pearsall
49ers · Florida
#31
WR
43%
FAIR
C
Rd 1
Xavier Legette
Panthers · South Carolina
#32
WR
81%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Keon Coleman
Bills · Florida St.
#33
WR
52%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Ladd McConkey
Chargers · Georgia
#34
WR
84%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Ruke Orhorhoro
Falcons · Clemson
#35
DT
23%
BUST
D
Rd 2
Jer'Zhan Newton
Commanders · Illinois
#36
DL
24%
BUST
D
Rd 2
Ja'Lynn Polk
Patriots · Washington
#37
WR
42%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
T'Vondre Sweat
Titans · Texas
#38
DL
93%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Braden Fiske
Rams · Florida St.
#39
DL
68%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Cooper DeJean
Eagles · Iowa
#40
DB
132%
FAIR
B
Rd 2
Kool-Aid McKinstry
Saints · Alabama
#41
DB
70%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Kamari Lassiter
Texans · Georgia
#42
DB
126%
FAIR
B
Rd 2
Max Melton
Cardinals · Rutgers
#43
DB
29%
BUST
D
Rd 2
Jackson Powers-Johnson
Raiders · Oregon
#44
OL
61%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Edgerrin Cooper
Packers · Texas A&M
#45
LB
66%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Jonathon Brooks
Panthers · Texas
#46
RB
4%
BUST
F
Rd 2
Tyler Nubin
Giants · Minnesota
#47
DB
101%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Maason Smith
Jaguars · LSU
#48
DT
29%
BUST
D
Rd 2
Kris Jenkins
Bengals · Michigan
#49
DL
33%
BUST
D
Rd 2
Mike Sainristil
Commanders · Michigan
#50
DB
116%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Zach Frazier
Steelers · West Virginia
#51
OL
116%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Adonai Mitchell
Colts · Texas
#52
WR
75%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Ben Sinnott
Commanders · Kansas St.
#53
TE
39%
BUST
D
Rd 2
Michael Hall
Browns · Ohio St.
#54
DT
21%
BUST
D
Rd 2
Patrick Paul
Dolphins · Houston
#55
OL
80%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Marshawn Kneeland
Cowboys · Western Michigan
#56
DL
18%
BUST
F
Rd 2
Chris Braswell
Buccaneers · Alabama
#57
LB
34%
BUST
D
Rd 2
Javon Bullard
Packers · Georgia
#58
DB
80%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Blake Fisher
Texans · Notre Dame
#59
OL
77%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Cole Bishop
Bills · Utah
#60
SAF
80%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Ennis Rakestraw
Lions · Missouri
#61
DB
12%
BUST
F
Rd 2
Roger Rosengarten
Ravens · Washington
#62
OL
121%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Kingsley Suamataia
Chiefs · BYU
#63
OL
77%
FAIR
C
Rd 2
Renardo Green
49ers · Florida St.
#64
DB
79%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Malachi Corley
Jets · Western Kentucky
#65
WR
29%
BUST
D
Rd 3
Trey Benson
Cardinals · Florida St.
#66
RB
17%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Brandon Coleman
Commanders · TCU
#67
OL
77%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Caedan Wallace
Patriots · Penn St.
#68
OL
17%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Junior Colson
Chargers · Michigan
#69
LB
12%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Andru Phillips
Giants · Kentucky
#70
DB
42%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Isaiah Adams
Cardinals · Illinois
#71
OL
85%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Trevin Wallace
Panthers · Kentucky
#72
LB
126%
FAIR
B
Rd 3
Cooper Beebe
Cowboys · Kansas St.
#73
OL
133%
FAIR
B
Rd 3
Bralen Trice
Falcons · Washington
#74
DE
5%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Kiran Amegadjie
Bears · Yale
#75
OL
7%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Jonah Elliss
Broncos · Utah
#76
DE
45%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Delmar Glaze
Raiders · Maryland
#77
OL
155%
HIT
B
Rd 3
Calen Bullock
Texans · USC
#78
SAF
191%
HIT
B
Rd 3
Matt Goncalves
Colts · Pittsburgh
#79
OL
107%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Jermaine Burton
Bengals · Alabama
#80
WR
19%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Christian Haynes
Seahawks · Connecticut
#81
OL
43%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Tip Reiman
Cardinals · Illinois
#82
TE
84%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Blake Corum
Rams · Michigan
#83
RB
57%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Roman Wilson
Steelers · Michigan
#84
WR
27%
BUST
D
Rd 3
Zak Zinter
Browns · Michigan
#85
OL
41%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Dominick Puni
49ers · Kansas
#86
OL
171%
HIT
B
Rd 3
Marist Liufau
Cowboys · Notre Dame
#87
LB
48%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
MarShawn Lloyd
Packers · USC
#88
RB
11%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Tykee Smith
Buccaneers · Georgia
#89
DB
107%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Elijah Jones
Cardinals · Boston Col.
#90
DB
14%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Ty'Ron Hopper
Packers · Missouri
#91
LB
57%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Jalen McMillan
Buccaneers · Washington
#92
WR
27%
BUST
D
Rd 3
Adisa Isaac
Ravens · Penn St.
#93
DE
7%
BUST
F
Rd 3
Jalyx Hunt
Eagles · Houston Christian
#94
DE
113%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
DeWayne Carter
Bills · Duke
#95
DT
24%
BUST
D
Rd 3
Jarrian Jones
Jaguars · Florida St.
#96
DB
58%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
McKinnley Jackson
Bengals · Texas A&M
#97
DL
33%
BUST
D
Rd 3
Payton Wilson
Steelers · North Carolina St.
#98
LB
61%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Kamren Kinchens
Rams · Miami (FL)
#99
SAF
60%
FAIR
C
Rd 3
Luke McCaffrey
Commanders · Rice
#100
WR
44%
FAIR
C

2023 class · 2025 class · Change the bust line to re-grade every class.