Teams / Giants
Team

Giants

New York · rank #28 of 32

D
DraftLedger grade
At a 40% bust line
Rounds 1–3 · 2000–2025 drafts. Change settings
81
Picks graded
15%
Hit rate
37%
Bust rate
86%
Value vs slot (100% = par)
By draft class
Grade for each year
D
C
D
B
A
A
D
C
C
D
B
F
F
C
D
C
C
C
B
D
B
F
D
D
B
D
0001020304050607080910111213141516171819202122232425

Each bar compares this class with the other 31 teams’ classes that same year.

The ledger
Every pick, scored against its slot
Year
Player
Pick
Pos
Value vs slot
Status
Grade
2025
Abdul Carter
Round 1 · Penn St.
#3
DE
19%
BUST
F
2025
Jaxson Dart
Round 1 · Mississippi
#25
QB
65%
FAIR
C
2025
Darius Alexander
Round 3 · Toledo
#65
DT
37%
BUST
D
2024
Malik Nabers
Round 1 · LSU
#6
WR
44%
FAIR
C
2024
Tyler Nubin
Round 2 · Minnesota
#47
DB
101%
FAIR
C
2024
Andru Phillips
Round 3 · Kentucky
#70
DB
42%
FAIR
C
2023
Deonte Banks
Round 1 · Maryland
#24
DB
65%
FAIR
C
2023
John Michael Schmitz
Round 2 · Minnesota
#57
OL
119%
FAIR
C
2023
Jalin Hyatt
Round 3 · Tennessee
#73
WR
35%
BUST
D
2022
Kayvon Thibodeaux
Round 1 · Oregon
#5
DE
48%
FAIR
C
2022
Evan Neal
Round 1 · Alabama
#7
OL
19%
BUST
F
2022
Wan'Dale Robinson
Round 2 · Kentucky
#43
WR
50%
FAIR
C
2022
Joshua Ezeudu
Round 3 · North Carolina
#67
OL
23%
BUST
D
2022
Cordale Flott
Round 3 · LSU
#81
CB
106%
FAIR
C
2021
Kadarius Toney
Round 1 · Florida
#20
WR
10%
BUST
F
2021
Azeez Ojulari
Round 2 · Georgia
#50
OLB
39%
BUST
D
2021
Aaron Robinson
Round 3 · Central Florida
#71
DB
6%
BUST
F
2020
Andrew Thomas
Round 1 · Georgia
#4
T
63%
FAIR
C
2020
Xavier McKinney
Round 2 · Alabama
#36
S
112%
FAIR
C
2020
Matt Peart
Round 3 · Connecticut
#99
T
46%
FAIR
C
2019
Daniel Jones
Round 1 · Duke
#6
QB
67%
FAIR
C
2019
Dexter Lawrence
Round 1 · Clemson
#17
DT
111%
FAIR
C
2019
Deandre Baker
Round 1 · Georgia
#30
CB
20%
BUST
F
2019
Oshane Ximines
Round 3 · Old Dominion
#95
DE
30%
BUST
D
2018
Saquon Barkley
Round 1 · Penn St.
#2
RB
97%
FAIR
C
2018
Will Hernandez
Round 2 · Texas-El Paso
#34
G
91%
FAIR
C
2018
Lorenzo Carter
Round 3 · Georgia
#66
DE
110%
FAIR
C
2018
B.J. Hill
Round 3 · North Carolina St.
#69
DT
166%
HIT
B
2017
Evan Engram
Round 1 · Mississippi
#23
TE
146%
FAIR
B
2017
Dalvin Tomlinson
Round 2 · Alabama
#55
DT
212%
HIT
A
2017
Davis Webb
Round 3 · California
#87
QB
1%
BUST
F
2016
Eli Apple
Round 1 · Ohio St.
#10
CB
66%
FAIR
C
2016
Sterling Shepard
Round 2 · Oklahoma
#40
WR
116%
FAIR
C
2016
Darian Thompson
Round 3 · Boise St.
#71
S
48%
FAIR
C
2015
Ereck Flowers
Round 1 · Miami (FL)
#9
T
83%
FAIR
C
2015
Landon Collins
Round 2 · Alabama
#33
S
138%
FAIR
B
2015
Owamagbe Odighizuwa
Round 3 · UCLA
#74
DE
9%
BUST
F
2014
Odell Beckham Jr.
Round 1 · LSU
#12
WR
95%
FAIR
C
2014
Weston Richburg
Round 2 · Colorado St.
#43
OL
104%
FAIR
C
2014
Jay Bromley
Round 3 · Syracuse
#74
DT
28%
BUST
D
2013
Justin Pugh
Round 1 · Syracuse
#19
T
139%
FAIR
B
2013
Johnathan Hankins
Round 2 · Ohio St.
#49
DT
224%
HIT
A
2013
Damontre Moore
Round 3 · Texas A&M
#81
DE
38%
BUST
D
2012
David Wilson
Round 1 · Virginia Tech
#32
RB
6%
BUST
F
2012
Rueben Randle
Round 2 · LSU
#63
WR
60%
FAIR
C
2012
Jayron Hosley
Round 3 · Virginia Tech
#94
DB
26%
BUST
D
2011
Prince Amukamara
Round 1 · Nebraska
#19
DB
113%
FAIR
C
2011
Marvin Austin
Round 2 · North Carolina
#52
DT
11%
BUST
F
2011
Jerrel Jernigan
Round 3 · Troy
#83
WR
20%
BUST
F
2010
Jason Pierre-Paul
Round 1 · South Florida
#15
DE
187%
HIT
B
2010
Linval Joseph
Round 2 · East Carolina
#46
DT
257%
HIT
A
2010
Chad Jones
Round 3 · LSU
#76
DB
0%
BUST
F
2009
Hakeem Nicks
Round 1 · North Carolina
#29
WR
75%
FAIR
C
2009
Clint Sintim
Round 2 · Virginia
#45
LB
9%
BUST
F
2009
Will Beatty
Round 2 · Connecticut
#60
T
104%
FAIR
C
2009
Ramses Barden
Round 3 · Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo
#85
WR
17%
BUST
F
2009
Travis Beckum
Round 3 · Wisconsin
#100
TE
31%
BUST
D
2008
Kenny Phillips
Round 1 · Miami (FL)
#31
DB
42%
FAIR
C
2008
Terrell Thomas
Round 2 · USC
#63
DB
59%
FAIR
C
2008
Mario Manningham
Round 3 · Michigan
#95
WR
136%
FAIR
B
2007
Aaron Ross
Round 1 · Texas
#20
DB
63%
FAIR
C
2007
Steve Smith
Round 2 · USC
#51
WR
52%
FAIR
C
2007
Jay Alford
Round 3 · Penn St.
#81
DT
21%
BUST
D
2006
Mathias Kiwanuka
Round 1 · Boston Col.
#32
DE
96%
FAIR
C
2006
Sinorice Moss
Round 2 · Miami (FL)
#44
WR
14%
BUST
F
2006
Gerris Wilkinson
Round 3 · Georgia Tech
#96
LB
35%
BUST
D
2005
Corey Webster
Round 2 · LSU
#43
DB
134%
FAIR
B
2005
Justin Tuck
Round 3 · Notre Dame
#74
DE
260%
HIT
A
2004
Philip Rivers
Round 1 · North Carolina St.
#4
QB
205%
HIT
A
2004
Chris Snee
Round 2 · Boston Col.
#34
G
193%
HIT
B
2003
William Joseph
Round 1 · Miami (FL)
#25
DT
32%
BUST
D
2003
Osi Umenyiora
Round 2 · Troy
#56
DE
208%
HIT
A
2003
Visanthe Shiancoe
Round 3 · Morgan St.
#91
TE
207%
HIT
A
2002
Jeremy Shockey
Round 1 · Miami (FL)
#14
TE
161%
HIT
B
2002
Tim Carter
Round 2 · Auburn
#46
WR
26%
BUST
D
2002
Jeff Hatch
Round 3 · Pennsylvania
#78
T
2%
BUST
F
2001
Will Allen
Round 1 · Syracuse
#22
DB
129%
FAIR
B
2001
Will Peterson
Round 3 · Western Illinois
#78
DB
119%
FAIR
C
2000
Ron Dayne
Round 1 · Wisconsin
#11
RB
30%
BUST
D
2000
Cornelius Griffin
Round 2 · Alabama
#42
DT
188%
HIT
B
2000
Ron Dixon
Round 3 · Lambuth
#73
WR
18%
BUST
F
Takes on Giants
What fans are saying

New York Giants draft history, graded

At DraftLedger's default 40% bust line, the Giants grade D for their first-three-round picks from 2000 through 2025, ranking #28 of 32 teams. Of 81 picks, 15% were hits (at least 150% of what the slot usually produces) and 37% were busts. Move the bust line on the page above to see the ranking change.

Best picks for the slot: Philip Rivers, Linval Joseph, Jason Pierre-Paul, Justin Tuck. Biggest misses: Ron Dayne, Kadarius Toney, David Wilson, Evan Neal.

See every class on the NFL draft classes page, or how the grades work.